Posted on 04/08/2026 9:50:43 PM PDT by Morgana
I’ve been spending a lot of time reflecting on how good my life is right now. It’s been spring in Central Texas since February, and the program I teach at has had classes outside, like next to a turtle pond and a running creek. I‘ve found myself thinking of how wonderful it is to see the fish swimming in the stream, to see the turtles sunning themselves on the rocks, to feel the sun and the breeze on my face, to smell the Texas Mountain Laurel bushes with flowers that smell like grape candy, to have a job where I help others, to have long-desired writing and speaking opportunities, to work in an intellectually stimulating environment, to live in a lovely apartment with my sweet, cuddly cat, to have close friends and kind coworkers and to be able to share that happiness with my family.
So, I’m glad that a doctor didn’t help me kill myself when I was a clinically depressed autistic teenager, as one poor Netherlands adolescent experienced in 2023.
He’s not the only clinically depressed autistic person to die by euthanasia in the Netherlands. In addition to the 2026 news story about his death, there was a similar story in the news in 2023. According to a recent article in the Atlantic, psychiatric euthanasia for Dutch teenagers with “terminal” mental illnesses is a “thing.”
In his interview for the National Post’s story on the issue, Canadian psychiatrist and mental health expert Sonu Gaind asserted, “To say, ‘this is now a terminal psychiatric condition’ has no scientific basis. The whole concept is nebulous.”
Sonu Gaind is right. I am not sure what would make a psychiatrist decide that a teenager whose brain is still developing is “terminally” mentally ill. Then again, there is widespread ableism in mental healthcare; that’s why American disability rights advocates spearheaded an X hashtag campaign called #MyAbleistTherapist. For instance, a therapist once announced to me that my depression and neurological disabilities were so severe that I would never work. Did this teenager’s providers give him a similar message, except they went a step further and suggested that he be killed?
As I’ve noted, this diagnosis of “terminal” psychiatric illness is generally opposed by disability justice advocates, disability studies scholars, etc. For instance, journalist Steve Silberman, whose book Neurotribes is viewed as the definitive history of the neurodiversity movement, remarked on a 2023 report about euthanasia for autism by asserting, “Horrific. #Autistic adults in the Netherlands are choosing medically assisted suicide because they can no longer stand the pain of loneliness.” In a 2015 editorial opposing Washington D.C.’s “MAiD” bill, internationally recognized disability justice advocate Ly Xīnzhèn M. Zhǎngsūn Brown notes:
“Our world is dominated by public discourse that considers disabled lives inherently defective, burdensome, suffering, and not worth living.”
“MAiD” programs and other forms of violence that spring from this attitude are an injustice to disabled people of all ages. But declaring an autistic teenager’s mental illness “terminal” and euthanizing him takes that attitude to a ridiculous extreme. Even though I know that some “MAiD” advocates are fine with euthanizing children, I can’t help but be reflexively surprised that even the most vociferous “MAiD” acolyte wouldn’t think that euthanizing an autistic teenager is absurd.
But perhaps this is what happens when powerful people decide that “MAiD” is no different than any other “medical procedure.” For instance, in an article in the Canadian Journal of Bioethics called “What’s so Special About Medically Assisted Dying?,” bioethicist Wayne Sumner asserts:
If more awareness, more providers, and more support are good things for these other services, why are they a bad thing for MAiD? Why should we think differently about MAiD than we do about other medical procedures? What’s so special about MAiD?”
I guess if you think that death is no big deal, then you won’t mind snuffing out the life of an disabled teenager.
This cultural climate is one of the reasons that so many disability justice advocates oppose any “MAiD.” I think disability justice “MAiD” opponents generally understand that many Oregon model “MAiD” proponents would never think of euthanizing an autistic teenager. But the general consensus is that some “MAiD” proponents have no such compunction, so it’s best to nip the US “MAiD” movement in the bud, before it gets out of control. Author Note: For a description of the kind of future that disabled adolescents deserve, view the 2024 PSA for World Down Syndrome Day called “Assume That I Can.”
Meghan is a disability instructor and a member of the EPC-USA board.
Her entire first paragraph is written in such a flighty, fluffy and lyrical way, I was just about to stop reading, when she finally got to her main point. She’s right, teen years can be difficult enough without being both autistic and clinically depressed. One does not necessarily be get the other.
A young person will need to learn some degree of self reliance, when all the adults around you seem so ready to give up on you as a project worth being completed.
If such a teen is very fortunate, they have learn to pray for spiritual strength and wisdom.
Tell me again how the left aren’t the real nazis?
I hear yuh - but she didn't write it to be excerpted here at Free Republic.
We must make allowances for that.
Regards,
Mental diseases are quite treatable.
And depressed people get well often by just switching environment.
Picky, I know, but she'll go further as a writer if her grammar improves. ..."the program where I teach" would be much better.
It used to be, we were saving people attempting to commit suicide.
Now, we are helping them to do it?!
You're right, and I mentally lodged the same complaint, because the first time I scanned her sentence it didn't parse, the second time was better though it seemed inside out, but the third time I realized the problem and compensated, slightly grumpily.
Her reader shouldn't have to do that. I'm with you, picky as we may be.
The left are always the Nazi’s, the party of death and destruction, faithfully doing the work of their father, the Devil.
Those I know who have started on the supplements had immediate results. For them the depression is gone. Clinical depression or manic depression in females often comes with the onset of puberty. They are referred to by acquaintances and parents as "moody girls," but that straightens out as soon as they start getting vitamin D. Depression (not sadness) is simply a vitamin deficiency.
Beget.
Clinical depression is not really a mental disease. It is vitamin D deficiency. See #10. Changing environment from a cloudy climate to a warm sunny climate will, indeed, cure the depression.
Canada is doing it wholesale for any malady. Go to the doctor for a severe cough and you will be offered the opportunity to end it all under medical supervision. Canada is working more aggressively than the USA to replace its population.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.