Posted on 06/14/2007 9:11:34 AM PDT by InfantryMarine
Edited on 06/18/2007 4:54:56 PM PDT by Admin Moderator. [history]
Awesome inescapable logic.
Good essay, Marine. But you know the blissninnies will see it as a paradoxical excuse for violence (shudder) that they think they can hide from, right?
S/F
TC
Excellent article. He persuaded me, and he didn’t need to use force to do it.
Well stated. The logic is undeniable, even though the paranoid socialists still seek ways to disarm America for the very reason that the Second Amendment was created...
Uhhhh...because the uncivilized guys had swords?
Very good. Short and sweet.
-b-
Awesome inescapable logic.
Deserves repeating
“blissninnies”
Outstanding!
I have to disagree. The Major left out the third way, irrational/emotional appeal.
“Awesome inescapable logic.”
Not to the hoplophobes or authoritarians in our society.
Excellent article.
Hmm. I wonder if I can sue someone who mugs me under Anti-Trust laws...
I have often tried to explain the change in behavior with regards to responsible armed citizens. It changed my behavior and attitude unknowingly. It took a year for me to notice. But I have never been able to explain it with such eloquence as is stated above.
Prior to CCW, I was prone to be more aggressive when threatened, out of fear. My attitude was to get the upperhand ASAP if there was an imminent threat in order to survive long enough to escape. In fact, a self defense course I observed long ago was teaching women to attack viciously at the eyeballs and groin if they feared for their lives. To act aggressively immediately and as soon as the attacker was on defense, make a run for it.
With a concealed weapon, I have an alternative because I know that the odds are at least even and likely tilted in my favor. I have many more options.
I tend to be ok with behaving like a sissy to avoid confrontation or escalation as long as I am armed. I think it is because I ma confident and feel less threatened. I am very humble and polite when confrontation arises these days.
ping
This article is just one of the reasons why there are some in society that would like to deep freeze all Marines and only thaw them during wartime....
Heck, they have already started it with Ted Williams....
But that passes for reason among liberals.
Reason and force. It is helpful to repeat words attributed to Thomas Jefferson. “Government is not about reason. Government is about force.”
The Major left out the third way, irrational/emotional appeal.
That's persuasion. I agree that irrationality is often used to apply to emotional appeal. It is also true that to act based on ones emotions rather than reason is irrational. Actions based on reason are rational. Appeal to emotion is an attempt to manipulate people to act on their emotions rather than reason. But because a person acts with consent then it is still persuasion.
That they don't know they're being manipulated via their mysticism does not relinquish them from being responsible (held accountable) for their actions. Heck, most people aren't aware of mysticism. If they were, they'd eliminate it. Neither the irrational persuader or the person being manipulated can be divorced from their chosen actions.
They both acted with irrationality. One acted out of ignorance and the persuader acted with intent. Intent to circumvent the reason of person he wants to manipulate. It is in this process that the persuader chooses to turn against himself (acting irrationally) by manipulating his victim to act on irrationality (act on emotions) rather than reason. The persuader is the lesser person and tries to bring down the better person to act irrationally.
It's a mainstay of politicians, bureaucrats and other parasitical elites.
Great essay Marine. Are you the author?
However, you will find that many here, while they agree with you [and I] about our unalienable right to carry arms, - will disagree with the Constitutional [and libertarian] non- aggression principle, - usually stated as "do not initiate force or fraud, or "if it harms none, do what you will, or "treat others as you'd like to be treated, or " live and let live. "
This disconnect in logic is one of the major puzzles of conservative thinking.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.