|This thread has been locked, it will not receive new replies.|
|Locked on 03/13/2007 5:52:40 AM PDT by Lead Moderator, reason:|
Skip to comments.American Idol 2007--Live Thread (Part I)
Posted on 01/15/2007 3:32:39 PM PST by silent_jonny
Haley doesn't sing loud enough.....
I like Haley this week. Hate the song tho.
Haley does not have a stong voice...the DIVAS are up...and she is lost in that crowd
It sounds fairly nice even though I don't know what song this is.
Randy got it...no pizazz. She is very attractive. Very.
No "yo" in it ... whatever the he!! it was.
Simon is right about her not making an impression.
My daughter (adult) just informed me that when the Whitney song "You Bring Me Love" came out, she thought it was, "you bring meat loaf". LOL. (more loaf than I'll ever need)
As much as people ridicule Simon...he is honest and for the most part, has a good ear (in my opinion) COurse last year he and I were almost together on every weeks critiques too LOL
She was a gymnist when she was a little girl. Pretty good at it too, judging by the video we see. Had to quit because of injury.
Again, I have no idea what this song is ...
Randy: "I wasn't jumping up and down ... But there was no pizazz. No YO! in it. Needs some wow."
Paula: "You look great up there." Uh-oh.
Simon: "I thought it was horrible. It was like some ghastly horrible high school performance. I told Paula during the song that I don't remember your name. You haven't made an impression."
Hailey says Simon doesn't like her - no he doesn't. She was okay. Sabrina was better. But didn't like either song.
I think Haley did better than the Skank, yet they seemed to be harder on Haley.
Have the contestants had tudes like this in the past? She wasn't that great. Fact.
Stphanie reminds me of a young Natalie COle
"Hailey says Simon doesn't like her - no he doesn't. She was okay. Sabrina was better. But didn't like either song."
I agree. What song was that she sang? (I think I'm old).
Man, these girls are cocky. Take some feedback. Especially honest feedback.
Simon was right when he said that one lady was refreshing because she can SING and is unassuming.
I didn't mind Haley's song.
Not as bad as Skankarella for sure.
She has a little Fantasia in her, though. :(
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.