To: Bear_in_RoseBear
Oh good. you did better. The link.
I am with you Bear. I don't agree with this assessment that Bombadil is Aule. My first choice of opinions is that he is Vala, but not one of the 14. I think he's one of a large group never named.
44,867 posted on
11/24/2003 5:35:08 PM PST by
Wneighbor
(Thorlo Sock company is American and supports US Troops!!!!)
To: Wneighbor
Howdy howdy evellybody!!! wassupanstuff? My day is sliding slowly down the drainspout of history...
Have I missed anything? :-)
To: Wneighbor
Bombadil isn't Aule... I don't think Tolkien, as a good Catholic, would ever have attempted to put a character who is, well, God the Father, into his story.
44,872 posted on
11/24/2003 5:44:47 PM PST by
JenB
(46 Days Til EntMoot; Nanowrimo Word Count 39,597)
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson