Posted on 05/17/2025 12:18:57 PM PDT by Signalman
This column really has two audiences. The first is moderate Republicans who are getting in the way of major fiscal reforms necessary to correct decades of financial irresponsibility. The second is Republican leadership who, in all honesty, are in a tough position trying to herd a bunch of unruly cats with personality disorders ranging from extreme anxiety to a desire to fight everything that moves.
Throughout this entire chaotic budget fight over the One Big Beautiful Bill, a dangerous delusion has begun creeping back into the Republican Party, especially among the moderate class and some in GOP leadership. It’s this belief they are getting once again that they won’t be able to win and stay in power if they don’t moderate on some of their positions.
Things like restructuring/reforming Medicaid, asserting fiscal responsibility, and pushing back hard against progressive social ideology.
Sure, they’ve talked a great game on immigration, but it’s been done through executive action. There has not been one serious attempt by the party to codify any immigration enforcement policies into law. There has not been any serious attempt to curtail the insane levels of government spending that have put us on a dangerous path.
What have moderate Republicans done? The “SALT Caucus” has demanded the federal government reward their states’ bad tax policies by reintroducing state and local tax deductions. Some, reportedly including President Donald Trump himself, have suggested tax hikes on the rich. More have wavered on ending the Green New Deal policies in the Inflation Reduction Act. They understand that Medicaid reform is necessary, but they are too uncomfortable with how it might impact their re-election bids.
The problem? There really isn’t much evidence in the past several years to justify their fears.
Trump didn’t win the presidency by compromising on his positions. Republicans didn’t retake the Senate by tacking to the center. The House didn’t hold together by hedging on tough issues. Conservative ideas won because voters rejected the Democrats’ failures and backed the vision Republicans offered. Republicans, in a moment of rare competence, had plans. The Democrats had fear.
Moderates want you to believe otherwise. They’re pushing to water down conservative reforms, cut deals on spending, avoid social issues, and retreat from the cultural battles that defined the campaign. Why? Because they think it’ll save their seats in the 2026 midterms. They’re even now still floating the idea that Roe v. Wade being overturned was bad and that Planned Parenthood funding is an issue we should let slide.
Medicaid reform? Don’t touch it. Budget cuts? Political suicide, they claim.
But if 2022 taught us anything, it’s that poor candidates, not conservative ideas, hurt the GOP’s momentum. And while the GOP should have won in Georgia, Arizona, and Pennsylvania, they didn’t because the candidates were terrible and were awful messengers of the alternative Republicans promised.
And in 2024, conservative messaging delivered wins across the board. There is zero evidence that elected Republicans trimming conservative principles from their governing style helps them win. None. The voters who turned out for Trump didn’t do so because they wanted moderation. They did it because they wanted action on the multiple issues that came with Democratic governance under the Biden administration.
Stop Playing Defense I do believe in the strategic use of rhetoric, and there isn’t always a time to say everything you want to say or do. But that isn’t the same as deciding to switch to being a moderate when that isn’t what you promised voters when you got elected (or re-elected). Voters don’t need to know everything you want to do, but they also need to know you’ll do what you promised you would. Turning around and doing none of what you promised will hurt you more often than being too conservative.
I’ll be blunt: Moderate politicians didn’t get us Republican governance. Conservatives did. And moderate voters looked between the progressive and conservative politicians and decided that the conservative ones had the best ideas for getting us out of the mess we were (and still are) in.
And it’s time to stop pretending we need to govern like we’re still trying to win purple districts. That isn’t the playbook that won Georgia, Arizona, or Pennsylvania. It wasn’t what got us a Senate majority. It wasn’t what kept the House. It wasn’t what put Trump back in the White House.
Every time the GOP wins a majority, we get the same tired script from the inside-the-Beltway crowd: “Tone it down. Don’t overreach. Wait until after the midterms.” And what do we get? Nothing. We win elections and lose the mandate because we let caution kill momentum.
Voters didn’t elect Republicans to be Democrats with better branding. They elected Republicans to do the things they promised. Cutting spending. Fixing the broken border. Defunding radical progressive programs. Reforming broken entitlement systems. Ending the DEI garbage that has infiltrated government and education. They didn’t vote for the GOP so they could turn around and abandon everything they ran on—they voted for our side so we could stop the left.
What the GOP Needs Is a Backbone Here’s what’s really happening: the moderates are scared. They’re afraid of being unpopular for five minutes on MSNBC and CNN. They’re afraid of upsetting entrenched interests. They’re afraid of standing firm on conservative values because they might get uncomfortable headlines.
But guess what? The voters who elected you don’t care about your cable news appearances. They care about results.
They care about whether you meant it when you said you’d cut the size of government. They care about whether you’ll hold the line on spending. They care about whether you’ll stand up for their values, not compromise them away to keep a seat warm.
The American people are tired of promises. They’re tired of Republicans winning elections only to govern like Democrats. I won’t go so far as to say they want bold, unapologetic leadership instead of political triangulation, but I will point out that they did elect Donald Trump twice (and the Biden years in between those two terms came amid a pandemic and an economic collapse).
And if you think backing off is what saves you in 2026, then you haven’t been paying attention to what got you here in the first place.
If You Promised to Govern Like a Conservative, Then Do It I get that some of these fights are hard. But that’s why the voters hired you. And if you think you can abandon your base and coast through the next cycle without paying the price, ask Mitt Romney how that worked out in 2012.
This isn’t about ideology for ideology’s sake. It’s about governing with integrity. Voters gave conservatives a mandate—so act like it. That means keeping our promises. That means following through. That means stop being afraid of doing what’s right just because it’s not easy.
You weren’t elected to be safe. You were elected to be bold. So grow a spine, get back in the fight, and give the voters the leadership they were promised.
The world’s shortest book: “Great Moderates In History”
Ah, good ol Rush
“moderate republican” is spelled DEMOCRAT. Change my mind.
“They don’t care - for the RINOs, losing the House majority in 2026 is worth it if they can impede Trump.”
Exactly right. They all both left and right work for the NWO anyhow. They have a common goal and that goal is hamper or eliminate any threats to their Global Order. Trump is the biggest threat right now.
Everything about this article is wrong.
“Moderate Republicans” actually benefit from the corruption in DC.
The feckless Republicans in Congress are dithering while a constitutional crisis has emerged. It is time for the
creation of a new party, and send the Republican Party the way of the Whigs and No-Nothings.
The exceptionally rich hide their income in tax-exempt "charitable" foundations not available to the middle class. Said foundations are often used for profitable purposes putting their competitors out of business with regulations foisted by the activist groups they support. I exposed the process with my first book and made a habit of exposing the practice in the early days of FR. Today, they launder the money first through intermediary foundations such as Tides.
“Moderate” conservatives are Democrat deep state plants.
Was the first Moderate Republican Alf Landon of KS? Or was there one sooner?
The problem? There really isn’t much evidence in the past several years to justify their fears.
Indeed incompetence cost everyone involved or not in controlling decisions.
The squishy moderates should be embracing Trump's agenda because the voters have said it's what they want. The voters have moved past appeasing the Democrats.
It's time for the moderates to do the same.
-PJ
One of the founders of the Republican Party, Horace Greeley (publisher of Karl Marx in his New York Tribune), was a Leftist even by today’s standards. Does that count as a Republican moderate?
I heard that the Rhinos tried to clean that they voted no because it didn’t go far enough for conservatives. That is absolute and total b*******.
We need to make a list of those and begin vigorously targeting them for primary defeats.
Primaries are where change can take place because you only need 10% of the eligible voters. Just a few dozen people can toss out an incumbent. That’s how AOC got elected.
A lot of “Rah rah git the tar and feathers” here but too many have conveniently forgotten how omnibus bills have gotten us to where DOGE and more are needed today. ‘One Big Beautiful Bill’ sounds catchy but, like all other omnibus bills, is laden with compromises and pork. It was probably great when it left President Trumps desk but now...
Congress spends too much time grandstanding and campaigning than buckling down on their responsibilities to their constituents. And ‘bill-writer aides’ from contributors do not proper staff make.
They should at least break bills down into categories (infrastructure, crime, etc.) and complete in-party debates prior to voting. Otherwise we have national embarrassments like this while the Evil Party gets to hoot again at our expense.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.