Posted on 02/09/2024 5:49:49 PM PST by MtnClimber
Global warming doomsayer Michael Mann of Penn State University has won his defamation lawsuit against critics Mark Steyn and Rand Simburg, proving that conservatives cannot get fair verdicts from District of Columbia juries. This is a huge, structural problem for the federal judiciary, because D.C. courts have jurisdiction over many actions regarding the federal government. Bias to the point of hatred of Republicans and conservatives by D.C. juries has made those courts a part of the Democrats’ armory.
If Republicans ever again get the Oval Office and majorities in both Houses of Congress, they must redefine the jurisdiction of lower courts so that actions involving the federal government rotate among all judicial districts. Democrats will fight this measure with a Senate filibuster, but Republicans can argue that the juries must “look like America.”
I am deeply worried for Mark’s health, as he has been very ill, and this massive setback might lead to worse health outcomes.
I rely on retired super-lawyer John Hinderaker, who attended some of the trial, on the question of the unjustness of the verdict:
The verdict was disappointing to those of us who followed the case and thought that Michael Mann presented a pathetically inadequate case. The jury actually agreed: it found that the defendants had defamed Mann, but awarded only a token $1 in damages, since Mann had failed to prove any. But it found that both Simberg and Steyn acted with actual malice–they didn’t actually believe what they said about Mann–and awarded punitive damages in the amount of $1,000 against Simberg, and $1 million against Steyn.
In a sane world, this case never would have gone to the jury. The legal standard is actual malice, which means the defendants must have thought, subjectively, that what they said wasn’t likely true.
(Excerpt) Read more at americanthinker.com ...
Nobody is safe with juries like this, especially if you are a conservative.
I am sure that his legal team had an appeal penned as soon as the trial began.
I am sure that his legal team had an appeal penned as soon as the trial began.
Ridiculous. Mann is a complete fraud.
D.C. Juries... and Judges , and 99% of the lawyers will NEVER deliver Justice. Like Ripley and Hicks say: Take off, nuke the site from orbit. It’s the only way to be sure
Some jurisdictions (NYS) require a bond posted fitst by the appealing party equal to the award amount and interest accumulates. This is before an appeal may go forward and is forfeited if the appeal fails.
Conservative=🎯
The left is just going to ‘legally’ confiscate the wealth of conservatives from here on out.
Justice by outlaw biker gangs.
Cheaper to hire those sorts, and they pay attention to their work.
DC certainly couldn’t pass the Abraham test — ten righteous men. A jury trial there offers no hope for anyone with the “wrong” skin color or ideology. You would have a better chance of getting a fair trial in the soviet union.
I think one of Steyn’s lawyers has already indicated they will use this as an appeal. If successful it would lower Simburg’s penalty to $4 and Steyn’s to $4,000
Whether successful or not, these amounts will not be a dent in the cost of Mann’s legal team costs. Though Mann is not on the hook for any costs at all, as he testified in court, he has not paid for any legal fees regarding his litigation.
Why don’t we do the same to them in conservative states?
For those that don’t know.... Mann is the “Hockey Stick” and “Fudge factor” guy. He wrote software to rig the temperature Climate numbers. His software was leaked along with the code and code comments.
That was a mistake.
I hope the appeal does better.
‘Mark Steyn represented himself …
‘That was a mistake.’
He may not have had much choice - the case went on for 12 years, and the commentators at ‘Steyn On-Line’ indicated that the kind of lawyers used in this case typically run at $1,500 / hour to $2,500 / hour.
Plus his co-defendant had standard legal representation (and she sounded pretty darn good) and he got rail-roaded as well.
The District of Columbia has not lately been the place for equal justice under the law; sadly that vindictive POS Mann and his crew were the one’s who got to choose the venue.
Can we invite the Brits back to burn DC again?
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.