Posted on 03/13/2023 10:49:28 AM PDT by nickcarraway
The internet is divided over people ordering catering from chains like Chipotle to hack their weekly meal prep. We crunched the numbers.
In a TikTok video from January, fashion influencer Madi Webb unboxes an enormous catering delivery from a nearby Brazilian restaurant. “I feel like I just cracked the code,” she says, explaining that the order of chicken and veggies cost only $100 for a week of lunches.
Since then, all over social media, people like Webb are claiming they’re ordering catering from local restaurants and big chains to hack their weekly meal prep. They take the food home, portion it up, and fridge or freeze it to eat all week. The argument? It’s theoretically cheaper than buying groceries and easier than cooking a whole bunch of food at once.
Reactions to the hack fall in either the eye-roll or the this-is-genius camps. “Consider me influenced,” one TikTok user replied to Webb’s video. Others were outraged: “I’m sorry but anybody who tells you it’s a better deal to order Chipotle catering as meal prep instead of buying the ingredients at a grocery store is probably a trust fund idiot who has literally never shopped anywhere except Whole Foods,” wrote one Twitter user.
But are bulk food orders really cheaper than cooking for yourself? We compared the catering and family meal packages offered by various large national chains—like Chipotle, Boston Market, and Panda Express—against their à la carte menus and homemade approximations duped by various content creators. The store locations for catering and regular menus were chosen at random, so they may differ slightly based on where you live. For food cost comparisons, we used $101 per week and $4.80 for a meal, based on the Bureau of Labor’s 2021 data on yearly cost of groceries for American households.
The scoop: Sorry, TikTok. Though it’s virtually impossible to make an apples to apples comparison between home and restaurant meal prices without recipes, and our per week grocery spend data is based on household sizes instead of individual budgets, making your own food generally costs less than ordering catering. But that doesn’t mean there aren’t some solid time-saving options out there—pending your diets, preferences, and health needs—a few of which aren’t that much more expensive than buying groceries. Scroll on for the best deals.
Chipotle
Catering hackers frequently name the fast casual burrito joint as a popular destination.
Bean, rice, and steak-filled burritos
Catering price: For 10 rice, bean, and steak-filled burritos, with a bulk order of chips and salsa, catering customers will pay about $12.10 per serving ($121 total).
Regular menu price: To cobble together the same meal from the à la carte menu, you’d fork up about $13 per order—meaning, buying 10 catered burritos is about $9 cheaper than ordering them individually. (That being said, all of Chipotle’s non-custom burritos come in under $11, if you don’t care about the chips and salsa.)
Grocery dupe: Even if you adjusted for inflation, it’s going to cost you less to make your own burritos in bulk and freeze them: According to a year-old video from food YouTuber Joshua Weissman, who frequently recreates takeout favorites in his “But Cheaper” series, a homemade riff with chicken could cost as little as $2.15 per burrito (or $21.50 for 10).
Chicken burrito bowls
Catering price: A catering package of deconstructed chicken burrito bowls that supposedly feeds 10 and comes with additional tortillas costs $10.75 per serving ($107.50 total).
Regular menu price: For a single chicken burrito bowl, you’ll pay about $9 per order at Chipotle. So, like the burritos (minus chips and salsa), it’s actually cheaper to just order the bowls individually—unless those tortillas hold a special place in your heart.
The takeaway: The cheapest move at Chipotle would be to buy 10 individual chicken burrito bowls for $90 ($9 each). Assuming you need enough food for 21 meals per week, that’s still only going to cover about half of them. That cost almost matches what American households currently spend per week ($101) for all food—and you know the shredded lettuce ain’t gonna freeze well, right?
Sweetgreen
You’ve got to want to eat a lot of Sweetgreen to even enter the ring: The minimum catering size at the salad chain is 20 meals.
Catering: A “Greatest Hits” bundle includes five orders of four popular menu items—the Harvest Bowl, Kale Caesar, Super Green Goddess, and Guacamole Greens—for $236.50 total. Sweetgreen also has a catering order minimum of $250, which means you’d need to add on snacks and drinks you may not want or need just to meet that cost.
Regular menu: If you were placing the same order à la carte, it would cost you around $264. So ordering a Sweetgreen catering package could save $14 at most compared with ordering 20 individual meals.
Grocery dupe: That being said, YouTuber Ethan Cheblowski, who regularly hacks restaurant meals at home, managed to recreate his custom Sweetgreen order. It included chicken, almonds, goat cheese, and Green Goddess dressing for about $6 less than it cost in store ($14.95, based on a recent calculation at a New York City location). It’s not a perfect dupe, but includes many of the same ingredients as The Harvest Bowl, which sells for $14.45.
The takeaway: Though Sweetgreen catering is cheaper than ordering à la carte, you’ll still pay at least $250 per catering package. Assuming you’re down to eat salad nearly three times per day, it could cover most of your weekly meals—but at a huge premium. And unless you have a big family or lots of roommates, you’re probably not going to get through enough salad before it wilts to oblivion in your fridge. A week’s worth of Sweetgreen catering at $250 is more than twice as expensive as the $101 a week that Americans supposedly spend on food. Meal prepping your own salads is way cheaper, and if you keep the components separated they’re not going to spoil nearly as fast.
Qdoba
Next up: Chipotle’s nemesis.
Catering: A 10-meal chicken hot bar catering package from Mexican-style chain Qdoba comes with grilled adobo chicken, rice, beans, guac, a bunch of toppings including salsa, and tortilla chips for $119.50 total ($11.95 per serving).
Regular menu: Doctoring a similar chicken bowl in-store costs about $9.85 per order, or $13.40 with additional chips and salsa. So it’s about $2.10 cheaper per meal to order individual bowls if you don’t include chips and salsa, and about $1.45 cheaper per meal to order catering if you do.
Special deals: If you order a Family Meal pack, which includes enough chicken, beans, rice, queso, salsa, and chips for up to five people, you’ll pay $39.95 total ($7.99 per meal). Granted, it’s light on the veggies, but you could easily change that with a bag of frozen ones. And unlike a salad, cooked components like these will keep well in the freezer.
Grocery dupe: Loosely judging from Weissman’s Chipotle burrito video, which features similar ingredients, ordering the Family Meal pack is likely still more expensive than cooking at home.
The takeaway: A catering package from Qdoba costs a little less than the regular menu when you include chips and salsa, but each serving is more than double what most Americans allegedly pay per meal. The Family Meal pack nets out at a better deal overall than catering, especially considering you could use it as a base and stretch it further with a few supermarket staples. Still, cooking at home remains the cheapest option of all.
Panda Express
Everybody's favorite mall chain is a hotbed for deals.
Catering: At Panda Express you can buy up to 16 meals worth of food for $112. The catering meal package includes two sides, like chow mein and greens, and two mains, like orange chicken and Beijing beef, for $7 per meal.
Regular menu: For one side and the same two mains, an à la carte combo costs $10.10—so catering is almost $5 cheaper per meal and includes an extra side.
Special deals: The best move here is ordering a Family Meal pack, which includes three mains and two sides and costs just $32 total ($6.40 per meal) for up to five servings.
Grocery dupe: Is the Family Meal combo cheaper than cooking the same meal at home? Doubtful. Though it’s certainly not a perfect comparison, back in October, Weissman managed to make orange chicken, chow mein, kung pao pork, and a side of rice for $2.85 per serve.
The takeaway: Panda Express is one of the best chains we’ve found for ordering food in bulk. On paper, a Family Meal deal at $6.40 a meal is just a third more expensive than America’s estimated per meal average grocery spend—but in practice, according to some bloggers who claim the combo feeds more like eight people, it could actually be on par. The Family Meal also comes with three entrees, so you could divvy up your portions to ensure a bit more variety than pre-made bowls like Sweetgreen.
Boston Market
Here’s one for people who idolize the rotisserie chicken dude, who ate 40 full birds in 40 days.
Catering: At Boston Market, a chicken buffet for five includes mashed potatoes, sweet corn, cornbread, and two liters of soda. It costs $64.99 total ($13.00 per meal).
Regular menu: That catering price ain’t cheap, especially considering a quarter chicken meal with two sides and fresh-baked cornbread will only set you back $10.99.
Special deals: This is where things get exciting. For $57.49 you can get an XL Family Meal, which comes with three whole chickens, six large sides—like mac and cheese and vegetable stuffing—and 12 hunks of cornbread. Boston Market doesn’t say how many meals this pack covers. But based on the regular menu’s quarter chicken meal portions, we can say 12 meals could be portioned out for $4.79 each.
Grocery dupe: Depending on whether you’re buying $4.99 Costco chickens (which are apparently not delicious anymore) or $8.49 ones from Whole Foods, you might not be able to make this much food for the same price—although homemade mac, cornbread, and other sides would certainly bring the cost down.
The takeaway: Boston Market is the best value meal deal we’ve found, coming in at one cent less than the average American household spends per meal. And while rotisserie chicken might get old after a while, the Family Meal comes with six entrees—so you could make a handful of different combinations.
You had me up till Campbell’s in a can. Might be fine for some, but the sodium content plays havoc with blood pressure and greatly increases cardiac risk. Ask me how I know...
It would mean that 8 hours of sleep would cost $400. Now if I can only find someone to pay me $50/hr for that, I’ll be set. Might even put in some overtime.
On the other point, if we simply look at the cost of ingredients, there is no question that making your own meals from food bought at the grocery store is cheaper, but in the real world, it is often cheaper to eat out. This happens because of the intense psychological pressure imposed by modern grocery stores calculated to assure that we buy more -- usually much more -- than what is needed.
“ If you are watching TV then your time is worth less than nothing, you would be making/saving money by using that kind of time cooking, and the activity is good for you.”
Who says you have to choose? Do both at the same time!
“ Three hours purchasing and preparing? Lol. No way.”
I cook nearly everything fresh. Nothing takes that long or it’s not on my menu and I have roast beef, chicken, steak veggies etc
For me eating out or ordering take out is cheaper. I bill hourly. And if it takes me two hours to make dinner that is two hours I could have billed. It works for my situation.
If you are a big family then cooking is the way to go and spread the labor around with everyone else helping to clean up after. Plus there are the benefits of family time.
“”Who says you have to choose? Do both at the same time!””
Oh yeah, I forgot about that, I guess I was thinking of the old days when the one TV was in the living room.
Grabbing a glass of wine and watching the Galloping Gourmet as you cook, would work.
I do my grocery shopping "European" style, in that I get what I need for that day on the way home. Tonight for instance, I'm picking up crushed tomatoes, tomato paste, an onion, a garlic bulb and some jalapenos. At home is ground chicken all thawed out, some shredded cheease and a can of pinto beans that I will make chili with.
Within an hour, it will be all done. Most of that time will be the chili simmering.
There are a lot of dishes my wife and I make at home that are quick to prep and easy to clean up after. Another favorite is cutting a sweet potato into thick slices in a dutch oven and tossing a whole chicken on top. An hour and a half later, you have a one pot meal with the chicken coming off the bones and the sweet potato is drenched in juices from the chicken.
I've tried all the "short cuts" over the years, like those meal kits (i.e. Freshly). Those things are a pain in the neck to make and there is so much wasted packaging.
Ping
Holy cow. I know, it works for you but geez, $600 a month? I too live alone and I budget for $150-200 per month which varies of course and imho, still too high but, like I said, I live alone. I’ve also taken advantage of CCs offering $200 to ‘sign up’ with them and then use that to get groceries.
Can’t see paying what you do but, whatever rings your bell.
So I guess life in Hawaii is not a total paradise?
If you are living by your self, (which you are) this might be a good idea. As we are six, (sometimes eight) and I find planning, shopping, prep and cooking fun this would not work for us. But it is an idea for when I am an old lady living alone with a goldfish.
Truly...the good old days! :)
I chop up a lot of onion, garlic, broccoli, zucchini, carrots and other veggies. Throw them in a frying pan with some hot oil, toss in the veggies, and stir. Simple one-pan meal and you can make endless variations. Reasonably good top sirloin goes on sale at Safeway all the time for $5 to $6 per pound.
Your prep time is theoretically worth money too. That may be where the savings come in.
Haha! Back in 80’s as a single guy working 2 jobs, a staple was ramen with cut-up hot dogs, broccoli, and cheese. I had a much better metabolism back then too.
I think you're being a bit optimistic.
This is a generation that is so lazy they created uber eats and the like. Now they are outsourcing their grocery shopping because even that's too difficult. They can't cook. They can't sew. Most can't change a tire or the oil in their car. A truly helpless, feckless generation.
You can buy a week's worth of lunches of chicken drumsticks for $10. How could this possibly be cheaper?
I think Hubby said Kudlow said it’s almost cheaper to eat out than to buy groceries — about a month ago.
I had co-workers who ate out for lunch every day.
They complained about not having enough money too.
$10 a day or more for fast food is expensive.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.