[grey_whiskers]

You wrote in Post #258

(Entire post cut-and-pasted):

I don't care what people THINK could or could not have happened.

If it is not recorded, then it is SPECULATION.

And yes I wrote in Post 261: "You're lying."

Your assertion, your rules.

Except one of the other non-Catholics said Post #220 that "No one has said His mother was not allowed to touch or mourn, or even following close by when He was taken to the tomb. "

And you didn't accuse HIM of speculation.

So were you lying?

Or trolling?

Or being bombastic?

Or putting your foot in your mouth without thinking it all the way through?

[MHGinTN]

Yo9ur Catholic mind is twisted. The comment I made was not, by logic rules, a speculation! Why are you so set on trying to have Elsie and me go at each other? (Now that is speculation, as an example.)

Your reasoning is twisted. How long have the catholiciism fairies been programming you? ... And you owe Elsie an apology for calling hi a liar. In the many years I have read his posts I have never detected a lie. You are merely a bitter Catholic accuser.

[Elsie]

If it is not recorded, then it is SPECULATION.

I stand by this.

I think someone said, upthread, prove me wrong.

[Elsie]

If it is not recorded, then it is SPECULATION.

I stand by this.

I think someone said, upthread, "Prove me wrong."

---

speculation

 

spĕk″yə-lā′shən

noun

1. Reasoning based on inconclusive evidence; conjecture or supposition.
2. A conclusion, opinion, or theory reached by conjecture.
3. Contemplation or consideration of a subject; meditation.

The American Heritage® Dictionary of the English Language, 5th Edition.