Jewish actor converts to Catholicism: the Virgin Mary ‘is my most beautiful love’

https://www.catholicnewsagency.com/amp/news/252786/jewish-actor-converts-to-catholicism-the-virgin-mary-is-my-most-beautiful-love ^ | November 10, 2022

[Elsie]

Read his post 87, I think it is.
Cut and paste and highlight spam.
Trolling.

To: grey_whiskers

...and it stuck by sheer force of repetition;

 

Hail Mary, Mother of GOD...

87 posted on 11/13/2022, 8:13:57 AM by Elsie (Heck is where people, who don't believe in Gosh, think they are not going...)

[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 82 | View Replies | Report Abuse]

[grey_whiskers]

That wasn’t the one I was thinking of.

It was 86.

Speaking of repetition.

[Elsie]

A while back, someone posted how to determine at least WHO posted a removed reply, but I failed to save the instructions.

[Elsie]

Speaking of repetition.

Showing of failing to check sources before accusing.

[Mom MD]

How do you know you have won the argument with greg whiskers? He calls you a troll. It’s the way he ends every encounter with non Q cultists

[grey_whiskers]

I have a cold and I’ve been up all night. And I was only off by 1 on the post number.

Get stuffed.

[Elsie]

#86 - nine pages of Scripture, giving examples of Scriptura, and you dismiss it with a wave of the imperial hand.

Stay behind the fence, little pup.

[MayflowerMadam]

“there are many accounts of Mary, whether appearing to people, or, God granting prayers after praying the Rosary, “

Demonic activity.

“sheer force of repetition”

Sort of a hilarious accusation when you consider “Say twenty Hail Marys”, or mumbo-jumbling while fondling plastic beads.

[Elsie]

Missing the mark.

Great definition of sin.

https://duckduckgo.com/?q=catholic+Missing+the+mark.+Great+definition+of+sin.&ia=web

[Elsie]

I get a mental image of TrigglyPuff at her best outrage.

[grey_whiskers]

They don’t give examples of Scriptura. That’s the problem.

Just repeating the phrase “it it written” is insufficient to establish the claim.

[Elsie]

Just repeating the phrase “it it written” is insufficient to establish the claim.

"Hail Mary...

[Elsie]

Wanna guess who DID save them???

Nifty trick for viewing deleted comments: http://www.freerepublic.com/perl/post?id=[Article#]%2C[Post#] (remove the brackets)

[grey_whiskers]

“there are many accounts of Mary, whether appearing to people, or, God granting prayers after praying the Rosary, “

Demonic activity.

You're incorrect.

“sheer force of repetition”

Sort of a hilarious accusation when you consider “Say twenty Hail Marys”, or mumbo-jumbling while fondling plastic beads.

Not at all. Quoting the phrase "it is written" over and over does not prove Sola Scriptura...which is itself a man-made doctrine, around 1500 years after Christianity started; and which had not been promulgated by any branch of Christianity until the reformation.

And when one prays the rosary, one is supposed to be meditating on specific events in the lives of Christ and the Apostles.

As the closing prayer for the rosary comes out and says, "O God, whose only-begotten Son, by his life, death, and resurrection, has purchased for us the rewards of eternal life; grant, we beseech you, that we who meditate upon these mysteries of the most holy rosary of the Blessed Virgin Mary, may imitate what they contain and obtain what they promise. We ask this through Christ our Lord. Amen."

[Elsie]

Quoting the phrase "it is written" over and over does not prove Sola Scriptura...which is itself a man-made doctrine, around 1500 years after Christianity started; and which had not been promulgated by any branch of Christianity until the reformation.

I would not toss around the phrase "man-made" so lightly...

---

https://catholicism.org/rosary-history.html

[Elsie]

The origins of the rosary are "sketchy" at best. 

 

Tradition does hold that St. Dominic (d. 1221) devised the rosary as we know it. 

 

The History of the Rosary (catholiceducation.org)

[Elsie]

...one is supposed to be meditating on specific events in the lives of Christ and the Apostles.

Must be hard - meditating on one thing while speaking something else.

[grey_whiskers]

St. Dominic credited the Rosary with helping him defeat the Albegensian heresy (sprit==good, matter=evil, briefly).

[Elsie]

Goodie for him.

[grey_whiskers]

I would not toss around the phrase "man-made" so lightly...

Sure you do, but mostly to attack Catholics. 😉 Of course you don't want to admit Sola Scriptura is man-made.

Because then you have to admit that man-made things can result in things which you hold to be both good and essential.

But if you claim it's inspired by God, and trustworthy...then that means individual revelations of the Holy Spirit still happen.

Even after the Scriptures were done being written.