Posted on 11/11/2017 4:46:08 PM PST by Twotone
On "Fox & Friends" this morning, reacting to the live footage of President Trump in Hanoi, I talked about the Vietnam war's domestic impact on the American psyche. It took many decades for that to change, and this Veterans Day movie pick is one of the cultural artifacts of that evolution in perception - a film about soldiering that wears its allegiance in its very title. It was released about six months after 9/11, in the spring of 2002, and in that sense is a movie about an old war seen through the lens of a new one.
The best thing about We Were Soldiers is how bad it is. I don't mean "bad" in the sense that it's written and directed by Randall Wallace, screenwriter of Braveheart (which won Oscars for pretty much everything except its screenplay, which was not overlooked without reason) and Pearl Harbor (whose plonking dialogue has been dwelt on previously in this space). Mr Wallace is as reliably uninspired as you can get. And yet it serves him well here. Pearl Harbor was terrible, but it was professionally terrible, its lame dialogue and cookie-cutter characters and butt-numbingly obvious emotional manipulation skillfully woven together into state-of-the-art Hollywood product. By contrast, in its best moments, We Were Soldiers feels very unHollywoody, as if it's a film not just about soldiers, but made by soldiers - or at any rate by someone who cares more about capturing the spirit of soldiery than about making a cool movie. It's the very opposite of Steven Spielberg's fluid ballet of carnage in Saving Private Ryan, and yet, in its stiffness and squareness, it manages to be moving and dignified in the way that real veterans of hellish battles often are.
(Excerpt) Read more at steynonline.com ...
One of those lost would have been a relative, had he not been KIA
Yes they do. They can lose a warn after sacraficing 50K+ lives for no reason but political expedience. Remember that!
Great movie. Hits you right in the feels.
Joseph Galloway: I’m a non-combatant.
Sergeant Major Basil Plumley: Ain’t no such thing today.
I was just thinking about him too when I saw this thread. He was n that battle
Wasn’t he Col Moore’s radio operator or something like that? I remember his excitement over the movie, long before it came out. I was thinking of him as soon as I saw the title. Could not remember his name. Wow. No posts for a long time.
click on the link, scroll down a bit and you will find Jack Smith's memoir of the battle that is the basis of We Were Soldiers Once and Young
an account of the battle of Ia Drang Valley by Joseph Galloway, the author of We Were Soldiers
This whole concept of civilian control of the military is highly overrated.
We are all friendly these days with most of the countries hundreds of thousands of US troops died and millions wounded fighting over the last 100 years.
Trump has Kelly all tuned up and ready to go when the MOVE happens.
Bruce Crandall, Medal of Honor, Vietnam War, Ia Drang Valley
‘Aloha Ronnie’ Guyer was radio operator at Ia Drang Valley for both Hal Moore and Basil Plumley
http://www.lzxray.com/articles/ronnie-guyer-ia-drang-photo-collection
Thanks. Hubby was Vietnam but has never talked about it. He still dreams about it. He speaks Vietnamese in his sleep sometimes. Dont know if youve read it but heres a link for another good red. Hubby was in this battle.
https://history.army.mil/books/Vietnam/7-ff/Ch6.htm
The late retired Lieutenant General Hal Moore was one helluva an officer and he embodied the spirit of leading from the front.
And also Jack Goeghegan. I knew him when he was a cadet commander at military college, and he was a very fine individual. He died there trying to save another man.
Oops nope. Dont think thats the one he was in. Hes in a book but I dont think its online.
Well, thats not too long ago! I hope he is well wherever he is.
For those interested in a first hand account of the Vietnam realities of American soldiers, i highly recommend this book.
JoMa
when is was in the army i bought “Street without Joy”. if i recall the battle was on Route 15 in and around where we had a base camp at ccamp Bear Cat near a South Vietnamese special forces post. after i rotated back to the U.S. i heard it was over run.
Gibson was great but I loved Sam Elliot in this flick. Great movie.
http://www.badassoftheweek.com/plumley.html
Custer was a pussy, you ain’t. The quotes attributable to plumley are hilarious. The pussies of this generation couldn’t lick the boots of this man.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.