[treetopsandroofs]

IIRC, except for Charlie X, most Enterprise (A) crew fatalities occurred planetside, so the better calculation might be red shirt fatalities among landing parties, rather than ship’s complement.

[Mr. Douglas]

That’s why Guy had a better chance of surviving if he stayed on board the Galaxy Quest, though it still worked out ok for him.

[AndyTheBear]

Indeed. The term red-shirt in the context of likely to die meant an extra beaming down as a security guard at the beginning of an episode. It did not apply to eveeybody wearing a red shirt.

[Bratch]