Posted on 03/10/2015 5:48:37 PM PDT by MNDude
My daughter has this problem-solving question for her homework. I'm feeling kind of dumb on this one. What do you think is the correct answer?
Mrs. Feltner wants to put a border on a baby blanket. The area of the blanket is 12 square units. Which shows how many units of materials she needs for the border?
A 12 units B 14 units C 15 units D 21 units
Having flogged the question to death mathematically, we can have even more fun by considering the practical matters that add another layer of ill-posedness:
Perhaps the blanket is rectangular has selvedge along one side (intended to be the bottom) and a border is needed only on three sides, or selvedge along two sides (used as the long sides) and a border is needed on only two.
Perhaps the border material is crocheting cotton, in which case the correct answer depends both on the perimeter of the blanket and the crocheting pattern used (and will be much larger than the perimeter in linear units).
You’ve actually got the point.
The problem isn’t one of math. It is training to look to the authority figure’s intent as to context and narrative in order to regurgitate the approved answer.
The correct answer would be 14(field perimeter) + 4(corners) = 18.
The answer was 14. The question wasn’t ambiguous and contained 2 constraints that were fairly clear. Every real number .... is not correct because constraint 2 limited your choice to one of the four offered choices.
Spoken like a true slave. Enjoy your chains.
Not only spoken like a true slave, also spoken like an innumerate one: of the four answers, three of them are correct, and 14 is NOT “more” correct than 15 or 21.
The question does say blanket. A 3x4 would be more suited for a blanket. The other dimensions, not so much.
Again...Stupid ambiguous question.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.