Posted on 02/02/2015 3:27:28 PM PST by Perdogg
I apologize for the vanity, but I know that FR is a community of avid readers. Last year, I read "The Hobbit", "The Lord of The Rings" and "The Silmarillion".
I read that Arthur C Clarke referred to "Dune" as 'The Lord of the Rings' of Science Fiction.
What are Freepers opinion of Dune (the book not the movie) and should I continue with the sequels? I saw the film 30 years ago, I remember receiving a sheet with a primmer at the movie theatre after buying a ticket.
also, is there a Gothic horror equivalent to "Dune" of "Lord of the Rings"?
The Sci Fi channel Dune and Children of Dune miniseries were good.
I have read every Dune book published including the novels by Herbert’s son.
The first three books are the best in my opinion.
Herbert created a compelling and immense body of work that,for me, grabbed my imagination. Highest recommendation.
It is a tough read for about 50-75 pages. Then it will all snap together, and after that it is a brilliantly thought out universe. The first four books are well worth reading.
Huge fan of the series. The original is fantastic, the movies are garbage, the miniseries not totally awful.
I found all the books written by Frank to be interesting they were vehicles for looking as different aspects of technology and genetics wrapped up in politics.
I really enjoyed the 4th book God Emperor of Dune as it examines the ‘choice’ God has to make on the topic of free will.
I have read the prequels supposedly taken from Frank Herbert’s notes. Writing not at the same level at all, There is a Trilogy that gives the background of the players in Dune, and how things evolved to the situation where House Atredies is going to Dune. There is another trilogy that explains the Butlerian Jihad and the limitations placed on Computers in that world. Then a set of novels that take up where the Frank Herbert books end to ‘finish that story not written very well but of interest to see where Frank Herbert was coming from.
No other sci fi book stands out in my mind as much. Probably been 35+ years since I've read it.
I need to set aside some alone time, pop some popcorn, turn off the phone and settle in for a nice long night of reading it again.
I agree with outofsalt.
I thought Dune was great, didn’t care for any of the books that came later. I kept hoping they would get better but IMHO, they didn’t.
Did not like any of the movie versions, but some of the casting in the 1984 film was interesting...too bad the movie had a crappy script!!!
As far as a gothic novel is concerned(I’m not sure it’s really a gothic novel, but it sure held my interest and is definitely imaginative),you may like the Gormenghast novels by Mervyn Peake..at least, the first two. IIRC, the 3rd in the series was written several years after the first two books, and also after Peake had suffered a serious illness, and seemed like a different book altogether..anyway, hope this helps!!!
Dune (the novel) is well worth the time.
The sequels are worthless, IMO.
...You will be tempted to read the sequel. DON’T!
Dune is a really good read but, stop right there. Trust me.”....
The same could be said for the movie sequels....I thought they really failed to carry on what could have been a whole lot better. ...the third was a dud.
I've seen the first Dune may times and consistently find things I didn't connect from the time before...Fun!
Very good book! Do give it an honest try. And forget the movie and mini-series (on SyFy a few years back?). They don’t even begin to do it justice, in a worse way than the LOTR movies did to the actual LOTR book.
Some of the aspects in the book to do with desert cultures, Arabic themes and languages, etc. have a hollow, awkward tone to them nowadays, but that wasn’t the case when it was written.
Books like this and LOTR just shouldn’t have movies made of them. It never works out to anyone’s satisfaction.
The trilogy is good and enjoyable. The sequel books beyond that lost me. You’ll find the movie of it a disappointment after the book (which often happens, of course).
(Only thing I liked about the movie was that copper and brass and wood took the place of plastics in vehicles and dwellings.)
The only books I have ever enjoyed as movies were by Tom Clancy. The only video product that I found to be better then the books is Game of Thrones.
OMG- somebody else that knows about that! I just re-read it; someone put it up on Pastebin. Napoleonic teddy bears. I loved how it challenged the assumption that 'we'll, they have FTL travel, so they must be undefeatable militarily'.
(raises a beer in salute)
One of the best Science Fiction novels.
dare I ask, how old are you? private reply is oK. :-)
Brilliance. Note the conditions in which they exist: The Butlerian Jihad eliminated and then banned all thinking machines.
No body ever thinks that we may be wildly advanced in a technological direction that a spacefaring alien race didn’t expect.
The road not taken altered my thinking forever.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.