American Idol 2014--Live Thread

americanidol.com ^ | 1-14-14

[kjam22]

Yeah... this is really bad. Even her parents can tell it is bad...

[Shelayne]

UGH.

Though this sweet Emily is really hitting some sour notes. Oy.

Look at the judges faking discussing Emily. Pfffft.

[kjam22]

I think Jlo was pissed they didn’t keep her

[Clint N. Suhks]

It’s all choreographed.

[silent_jonny]

As always, we weigh these decisions very carefully. And tonight we have decided not to use the save.

Audience boos, but come on. Emily herself didn't expect them to use it.

She remains composed throughout the "Breakaway" montage and the group hug with her fellow Idols.

And that's it for this week.

[silent_jonny]

Hi, Peggy! :)

I don’t even care who leaves. The majority suck and I only like a few. Bah humbug!

lol, well I'm taking some solace that MK is consistently in the Bottom Three. Eventually there won't be anywhere for her to hide.

[silent_jonny]

Hi, Shelayne! :)

[slugbug]

And then the judges will use the save and MK will live to sing another day!

[Lil'freeper]

Raise your hand if when P2 said the name John Mayer you said, “Is a douche.”

Me. It's a rule.

[advertising guy]

Evenin Mag

[Lil'freeper]

So, Kodaline. Loved the driving percussion and the perpetual guitar. Thank you Ireland for the former and thank you Edge for the latter.

[ken5050]

Emily lost because once again the Marines didn't have enough time to vote...voting hours should be extended for military personnel.

Kodaline wasn't.....but did you notice, the "refrain" in their song.."whoa-a-whoa-a whoa-a-a"..is almost a carbon copy from Phil Philips "Home"

PP is a very gifted performer..has a little Bob Dylan about him...quirky..he's gonna have a long successful career..

Bottom three was 'Two and a 1/2 women'

[ken5050]

Just wanted to give you some props..nobody ever responds to you...so when you logon tonite..you'll have one in advance..<

Seriously, in past threads we had a ton of West Coast Freepers who'd watch it later on..then pile on...where'd they all go?

[ken5050]

Did you catch the comment by Connick: "I'd love to be your mentor. I'd be in the hotel till 5 am working with you, trying to make each of you better."

Then watch Randy thinking, "S**t!!! I spend 30 minutes each day with the group.. toss out a few 'dawgs"..tell them to 'get real'..and cash my check..

[patriotspride]

How many sob stories and special interests must be served in a singing competition? I say none.

---

Agree. Haven’t been too active this season due to some pressing family commitments but enjoyed seeing your post :):)

[word_warrior_bob]

We started listening to Codaline and I quickly concluded “more whining pu****’s” and hit fast forward.

[Sir_Ed]

It’s difficult for me to watch because I don’t like the hosts and I don’t like the singers, except for Dexter...he reminds me of Taylor Hicks.

I don’t understand why Urban and Connick have to look like unshaven bums. If I didn’t know they were “stars” I’d think they were pulled from the nearest gospel rescue mission.

Ed

[ken5050]

I recognize about 1 in 20 of the songs...If it wasn’t for these threads..I wouldn’t bother to watch the show..

[miserare]

It is my sincere belief that Keith is stoned most of the time.

[miserare]

What a bunch of mopes! I listened to them for 2 minutes before changing the channel.