[Artemis Webb]

Tough call on Sinatra. I consider “In the wee small hours” to be one of the greatest albums of all time. But Sinatra didn’t write nor was even able to read music. His voice (in his prime) and interpretive skills were unmatched though.

[hampdenkid]

That’s a real compelling analysis — though I believe he did write “I’m a Fool to Love You.” I think the fact that he changed the face of popular singing (from crooner to swooner) will weigh heavily in his favor.

[jessduntno]

But Sinatra didn’t write nor was even able to read music. His voice (in his prime) and interpretive skills were unmatched though.”

Exactly. But ooooh, that phrasing...unmatched.

[Tainan]

Sinatra has chunks of people like Mitchell in his morning stool.

...;)