[silent_jonny]

Crystal Bowersox

She has the pimp spot again this week. Her song is "You Can't Always Get What You Want". She walks out with her trusty autographed guitar. Awesome! I'd like to have this song to keep. Perfect.

Randy: Yo! (has to wait for the audience to subside) Didn't think it was your best performance, but you didn't disappoint.

Ellen: You sang with such ease. You're born to be on stage. Added personality. Loved seeing that.

Kara: You're so comfortable up there. Easy to watch.

Simon: The interesting thing is, you came out here the 100% the clear favorite. But tonight is the first time that I think you were beaten by somebody and that was Siobhan.

Bowersox agrees. "She was a-may-zing!"

Simon: You have to kill every week.

[skateman]

Wow, talk about a suggestive pic!!

[CASchack]

My bottom three: Andrew, Tim, Katie

Going home: Andrew

Lacey was weak also.

[freedumb2003]

g’night jonny!

Thanks, as always, for hosting another fun night — no trainwrecks and I think reggae boy is a question of taste (although it was a white boy execution).

My take is Andrew is going home (I think people will give credit to Bobby Sherman for his gutsy call to do the Reggae version).

Highlight of the night: Paige was quite good after 2 weeks of terrible performances.

[nfldgirl]

I don’t know about anybody else here on this thread...I’ve not read all the posts, but I just want to add my 2 cents worth tonight about Simon’s and Kara’s comments on Crystal’s performance...I feel like they owe her an apology for the insinuation they made about her assuming she has the win in the bag. I never got that impression from her...they obviously don’t see what we see out here in America. They most definitely owe her an apology for the snarky comments they made.