[retrokitten]

I disagree with Simon here. Carrie Underwood was as wooden as they come and she not only won but has gone on to huge success.

[freedumb2003]

>>Carrie Underwood was as wooden as they come and she not only won but has gone on to huge success.<<

It is always a line — looking for that “X” factor that commends and demands the attention of the audience.

[bert]

Simon is talking from both sides of his mouth

Lynche was criticized for using the stage. Casey for not using the stage

Casey had the audience in his hand. He projected himself well

[ChicagoConservative27]

I bet Casey does some nude stuff.