Andrew Garcia
He butchers "Gimme Shelter". Terrible. Empty. Shallow. It's like something you'd see and hear at a jr. high talent show.
Randy: Dog, you know I love you. But man ... that was pitchy all over the place. Wasn't good. Sang under a lot of times
Ellen: What do I know? (certainly nothing about music) That was your best peformance yet.
Kara: (says she felt no connection) No intensity. I want to make you better.
Simon: I think I'm somewhere in the middle here. My gut says you were better in rehersals.
Kara had it right. He was just singing a song and putting nothing else into it. Dead weight.