American Idol 2010--Live Thread

americanidol.com ^ | January 11, 2010

[SunnyUsa]

Crystal is odd.... that was her best performance tonight but I just can’t see her being the AI

[silent_jonny]

Mandisa?

[slugbug]

Rumor has it David Cook will be singing Jumping Jack Flash tomorrow!

[RummyChick]

not sure if it is her story, her singing of that song, or me just relating to it..or all of the above..
but I felt like Paula while watching it..it brought tears to my eyes...

hope that woman doesn’t crash and burn ..because she is talented,..that is for sure....

[silent_jonny]

Lol, is there anyone Keith Richards hasn’t done drugs with?

Me :)

[silent_jonny]

I thought it was well-controlled.

I thought so too (re: Siobhan's scream)

[Cudjo]

re: Susan Boyle and Wild Horses, just wow, terrific

[Nea Wood]

To me the season that Taylor Hicks won was the best season for talent... Carrie Underwood and Bo Bice was the 2nd best and the one with David Cook was 3rd. The rest were just alright. :)

Couldn't agree with you more!

[silent_jonny]

That was the Fantasia year wasn’t it?

No, Mandisa was in the Hicks/McPhee/Daughtry season. The best season ever.

[nfldgirl]

I don’t know about anybody else here on this thread...I’ve not read all the posts, but I just want to add my 2 cents worth tonight about Simon’s and Kara’s comments on Crystal’s performance...I feel like they owe her an apology for the insinuation they made about her assuming she has the win in the bag. I never got that impression from her...they obviously don’t see what we see out here in America. They most definitely owe her an apology for the snarky comments they made.

[freedumb2003]

>>Mandisa?<<

That was her — thanks :)

Why they named her after a math function, I will never know...

[Cudjo]

I think Kara and Simon trashed Crystal tonight, if anyone acts like they’ve already won it’s Big Mike

[RummyChick]

to get you ready...Mick singing the song...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lfcisnVHtA0

[silent_jonny]

Happy St. Patty’s Day Eve, All!

Hi, O'Didi! :-D

[silent_jonny]

You aren't interested in what color family Snugglepuss is in??!?!? ;-)

LOL!! Can't say that I am, no :)

[silent_jonny]

BTW, I think Seacrest knew what color “snugglepuss” is without checking :)

[RummyChick]

I gotta say after watching that video of Mick strutting around and making those faces....I can just imagine how we would be laughing if one of those contestants tried it.....

[Palladin]

Agree.

[silent_jonny]

John Mayer is a douche.

That needs to be said whenever his name is mentioned. It's like a thread rule :)

[Palladin]

My top three:
1.Siobhan
2.Casey
3.Crystal

Bottom three:
1.Andrew
2.Lee
3.Didi