American Idol 2009--Live Thread II

americanidol.com ^ | 3-17-09

[silent_jonny]

.

For Ladyinred

[Majie Purple]

You do know that I was refering to a popular catch phrasw from a t v show,right? Jonny got it & tha’s who I intended to get the joke...if You do too,the more the merrier.

[maggief]

“LOLOL! I cropped it from that giant photo you posted :-D”

I KNEW I recognized that thang!

[maggief]

Still laughing ...

You are too much! :)

[EmilyGeiger]

Adam sang one of my favorite songs and I’m sorry I know I’m not right but I hated it!!!!!! I love Feeling Good, but he was way over the top and I know they all loved it, but I honestly hated it. I don’t like him, I don’t like his voice. He is way too theatrical and I only like theater in the theater...... Is something wrong with me? Loved Danny and Chris though. I liked Matt too, but I’m weird that way. :/

[Netizen]

Stage parents probably made her say the bully stuff. How dare Cowell criticize our precious snowflake!?

I wouldn't put it past them, looking for sympathy votes, early on.

[skateman]

Sure. You also realize that I was referring to the folks on this forum who seemed determined to be offended by any remarks critical of people who like gay sex?

[silent_jonny]

LOL ;)

[TonyWpi]

Hummm....you must be hetrosexual! Or Miss California!

I thought Danny and Allison were both great.

[Palladin]

Your typos aren’t half as bad as mine, especially when I get all riled up about Obama!

[jennyjenny]

I wondered about that too. I’m usually in total agreement with Simon but tonight I didn’t agree with him on anyone but Danny. It was kinda weird.

[silent_jonny]

I guess in the Rat Pack, Adam is playing the part of Liza Minelli

LOL!!

(And for the record, I like the non-PC comments here. For Pete's sake, is there no where left in the world where we can actually say what we think?)

[hugorand]

Aside from the dress, Paula looked very lovely tonight. Yes, Kara did look a little odd tonight, and she was lunging forward for some reason.

[EmilyGeiger]

Wow! Ten? Unbelievable voice on that girl. Beautiful.

[maggief]

[silent_jonny]

The thing that bugs me about Adam is he has to scream like he’s the lead singer of Skid Row in every. single. song.

Same here.

[Timeout]

Better get busy voting for Allison.
I just got through 6 straight calls in a row!

[Miss Didi]

At this point they always sing two songs...but thanks to the addition of Miss Smarty Pants to the panel we only get one.

[Palladin]

“He is way too theatrical and I only like theater in the theater.”

Girl, you hit the nail on the head! For seven years, I’ve been hearing Simon tell many wonderful young singers in the early auditions that they are “Too BROADWAY”!

Wel, what the heck is Adam, then? He’s Broadway to the n-th degree; to the max; he’s Exponential Broadway.

If he wins, I’ll neve watch the show again.

And not because he’s gay. I have gay relatives and friends whom I love. Adam is gay and CREEPY.

[silent_jonny]

I don’t care if they have a career...just not under the American Idol brand. Am I alone!??

No! I agree with you.

[retrokitten]

Totally agree with you guys!

I could care less what he does in his personal life. It’s the fact that he just can’t SING A SONG! He has to start screeching 3/4th of the way through every song that bugs me.