American Idol 2009--Live Thread II

americanidol.com ^ | 3-17-09

[silent_jonny]

.

For Ladyinred

[Miss Didi]

Randy: I didn't think it was precocious at all. I thought it was DOPE!

Mom Didi: What...they're taking dope???

Dad Didi: No, I think he called her a dope.


Mom is fine...she has been a bit bored with the show and admits sneaking over to O'Reilly sometimes when they are singing. She thinks that Paula "Adool" had better watch her back, though.

[Purrcival]

Hurt by Trent Reznor? Reznik? of 9 Inch Nails...Did a FANTASTIC video to go with it. You can’t touch Johnny Cash.

[retrokitten]

Mom Didi: What...they're taking dope???

Dad Didi: No, I think he called her a dope.

ROTFL!! After a certain age, all parents are the same. Glad to hear she's doing well. I am with her- this season is sort of dull so far.

[Netizen]

Mike is eating his words — sounds like he is mumbling....

It wasn't BAD, it just wasn't great either.

[Netizen]

I like her. Hope she goes far in the competition.

[Netizen]

I’m bored already with this kid.....

Same here and its not just this week. BORING

[Palladin]

Interesting post. It would be a hoot if the judges had to use their “save” so early in the game.

It would serve them right for messing up the original format.

[Jukeman]

I thought Scott, Matt and Anoop did good. They will go onto another round along with Kris, Gokey, Alexis, Allison and Lil. Adam was a disgrace to Johnny Cash and the writer of the song he did, June Carter. Hope he goes. I voted for Allison.

[Jukeman]

The same thing crossed my mind. Allison has something going for her.

[Netizen]

I’m just glad that Lil didn’t do ‘I Will Always Love You’. She didn’t take the easy way out. It wasn’t bad, just not memorable.

[silent_jonny]

I am just sitting here staring at the empty post box without words.

I didn't know what to say about Lambert either.

Neither did Randy Travis, LOL

[Netizen]

I thought LIL was short for Lilly?

Could be, but, Lilly might be short for Lillian.

[Palladin]

“Paula is the perfect foil for Simon.”

She is Gracie Allen to his George Burns.

[nufsed]

IIRC Gracie was very smart. I think Paula is the same off and on. But the stage analogy works.

[Sir_Ed]

Heh heh, that was FUNNY!

I can’t watch Adam or Meghan...Adam because he’s slimy, Meghan because of her hideous tattoos.

Ed

[Netizen]

And he is going to do RING OF FIRE?

I absolutely hated that! I think Johnny Cash was trying to claw open his casket. Worst of the night.

[Sir_Ed]

Oh my God, that is sickening...prancing sheep waving the flag around, mocking patriots, our flag and the National Anthem.

Disgusting.

If he’s in the final four, three or two I’m not watching it anymore.

Ed

[Netizen]

It is ruined — almost as much as “Viva Las Vegas” is ruined due to the viagra commercials.

I agree completely about Viva Las Vegas. One good thing about Lambert's version of Ring of Firing being SO HORRID is that id didn't sound one bit like Johnny Cash's.

[Netizen]

He got better on the chorus... .but the verse was REALLY REALLY lame

Yeah, how many words did Scott have to learn for that little gem?

[Netizen]

This is a very nice rendition of Jolene.

I like her, but, I didn't like this version of Jolene. didn't care for the arrangement either. Right now Alexis is at the bottom at Dial Idol. I'm hoping its off.