American Idol 2009--Live Thread

americanidol.com ^

[silent_jonny]

American Idol 2009

For Ladyinred

[nufsed]

I merely summarized the part of the thread for last night and tonight. If you can’t stand to have your comments critiqued maybe you should find a hand holding site. In fact, I didn’t say anything about you directly. So what’s the matter with you? Are you the hall monitor?

[silent_jonny]

Good night, Purple One :)

[silent_jonny]

They sure sound alike.

[nufsed]

If you don’t understand my reply, tell me. Your post was a waste of time. Read what I said before you waste everyone’s time and show yourself up trying to prove something no one is denying. Or better yet make your comments to the other poster instead of me, as you’ve been doing.

[Netizen]

I meant when they tell us who made it. Why have they removed the drama? they give us the 2nd and 3rd place people, and we all know who got the most.

[nufsed]

And now you’re invoking Prince. Careful, he might be gay.

[dead]

If you can’t stand to have your comments critiqued maybe you should find a hand holding site.

Having never posted on an AI thread before just a minute ago, I'm dubbing myself a neutral observer.

From where I'm sitting, you seem very touchy about having your critique of other people's critiques critiqued.

That's my opinion and dammit nobody better disagree with me about it.

[retrokitten]

There is someone like you (suspiciously like you) every single season since this thread has been going on. Your shtick is not original or even creative.

[skateman]

So you admit you have been paying scant attention to this thread? I don't recall you last night or ever being on this thread to offer your insightful commentary to the quality of the various contestants singing or not singing ability.

You would appear only to be interested incoming into the thread with the desire of picking a fight with cheap below the belt cuts and comments.

[skateman]

And now you’re invoking Prince. Careful, he might be gay.

Now you show your freeper AI thread ignorance. Purpleraine was a freeper would would get plastered and come into this thread to pick fights. Much like you have been doing.

I just gotta ask, are you gay?

[nufsed]

Didn’t come here to be creative or original, only to post my observation. I guess you’re the designated apologist for the innane comments.

[nufsed]

I don't know how many times I will prove you wrong on one thread, but it's interesting you keep coming back for more. I don't drink.

Just a minute, I'll ask my wife and kids if I'm gay.

Instead of spending more time on who's gay and who's not on stage maybe we could hear you comment about their singing.

You're 0 for 3, so be careful with your next blind accusations.

My wife says she's my beard, so anything is possible. She shoots better than me also. So two points on your side. If I sing next week on Idol, that will clinch the deal because nothing gets by a sharp guy like you.

[Netizen]

There’s a fishtalk person that does a thread, but, oddly enough it always seems to link back to their blog. Go figure! lol

[skateman]

Oh whatever, keep living in your dream world. Apparently reality is a tough concept for you to handle.

[silent_jonny]

From where I'm sitting, you seem very touchy about having your critique of other people's critiques critiqued.

That's my opinion and dammit nobody better disagree with me about it.

Awesome, dead :)

[retrokitten]

Didn’t come here to be creative or original, Mission accomplished

only to post my observation.

And that's all we are doing. You say we are posting "innane [sic] comments" but what you've come to save us? Please.

[nufsed]

Tell me the proper order before I can comment on your innane posts. Do I have to watch the show with you? Can I wait until the second night and comment on the singers? Am I alowwed to read the thread and reply to stupid comments?

What's your rule Oh Webmaster?

[nufsed]

I’m finished with you. Brush up on the wit and borrow some IQ points. See you next week!

[Netizen]

Maybe next week, we can even talk about the vocal qualities of the singers. Just a suggestion.

When the singers are good we comment on it. Most people here have commented on those whose voices they liked, like Mishavonna, Danny, Megan, Alexis, even Tatiana.