American Idol 2009--Live Thread

americanidol.com ^

[silent_jonny]

American Idol 2009

For Ladyinred

[Tuxedo]

Which has been more accurate? DialIdol or AOL? I find it hard to believe Matt G got the #3 spot. Allison a small surprise too. She was good but I like Megan a bit more.

[silent_jonny]

I think Allison, Norman (Nick) and Adam will be the 3.

I have a feeling you're right. But I hope Megan beats "Gentle".

[silent_jonny]

Thank you :)

(What does "RTP" mean?)

[silent_jonny]

But after what I’ve heard about last night and what we’ve had to put up with the last few months, I’m hoped and changed out.

I hear ya.

I think a lot of people, including some that voted for "that one", are feeling the same way.

[silent_jonny]

Oh! Von Smith. For some reason I thought we already cut him. Just wishful thinking.

LOL! Yeah, the worst is still to come.

[silent_jonny]

Some very good talent will get booted out even with the wild cards.

I agree. I don't know what they were thinking with this new format.

[silent_jonny]

I forgot who Nathanial Marshal is. Any hopes that next week’s show will be LESS of a trainwreck are gone :-/

[silent_jonny]

Hi, EG :)

I really didn’t care for any of them.

It was a mess. The only one that I can remember (in a good way) this morning is Allison.

[silent_jonny]

Now you see blue...now you don't...

Are you suggesting that The One uses something to cover his corpse-blue lips? I'm shocked! :)

[retrokitten]

It was surreal! I wouldn't know how to describe tonight's show to anyone that didn't see it.

Suck-tastic

[retrokitten]

Along with a button and a couple of Canadian quarters ;)

Hey the washer and dryer won't take them and I have to get rid of them some how!

[retrokitten]

I forgot who Nathanial Marshal is. Any hopes that next week’s show will be LESS of a trainwreck are gone :-/

Yeah, just when you thought it would be less gay-

TAH DOW! Gay-splosion!

[ken5050]

Just read the thread...... fantastic..best one in a long time.

Can anyone explain why/how the judges switched seats?...when I first saw it I thought maybe it was my TV..

BTW.."Satisfaction" is without a doubt the all time greatest R&R song EVER. Hands down. Nothing even comes close. I gues you had to be there..Didn't particularly like this version, but last night I was flashing back to the summer of '65..the Catskills, me, Elaine Fayman, and the back seat of my 1960 Studebaker Lark..I'm STILL grinning this morning..

[slugbug]

LOL Nathanial is another one that we won’t soon forget. So many drama queens in this year’s batch!

[Wolfstar]

It's like watching Helen Thomas morph into Ann Coulter. There ain't enough beer in the world! :)

Or like watching that toad, Harry Reid, morph into Cary Grant. Nope, no amount of joy juice, of any variety, would be enough. :)

[ken5050]

If Norman makes the top 3 tonight..it will be the moment that AI “jumps the shark”..think Sanjaya X 100

[Wolfstar]

I believe it's called Kenyan Blue

Ack! My eyes! Some people call him good-looking, but that has to be THE most horrifying presidential photo ever, and on several levels.

I'm no scared little mouse, but that photo even makes me want to run away and hide like our terrified little friend here:

[Wolfstar]

I forgot who Nathanial Marshal is. Any hopes that next week’s show will be LESS of a trainwreck are gone

Gack! The gay dude with those hideous chin studs and tatoos. What IS it about so many younger people these days that feels the need to mutilate themselves in such hideous ways? Even when they decide to ditch the studs, those things leave hideous disfiguring scars.

[Wolfstar]

in the #3 spot Matt Giraud

If Matt does get the #3 spot, it would indicate to me that there are plenty of anti O-type voters in the AI audience. Middle America still counts for something, I guess. :)

[Bahbah]

Thanks for the ping, Wolfstar.

He’s ugly, inside and out.