[Lijahsbubbe]

This is the best season by far.

Do you think so? I thought the best season was with Pickler, Daughtry, Elliot, Hicks and McPhee.

What a fun year that was! What does everyone else think?

[Lil'freeper]

I thought the best season was with Pickler, Daughtry, Elliot, Hicks and McPhee.

I liked that season, too. There was eye candy for the girl fans, eye candy for the guy fans, the Gherkin kept everyone laughing, and the Soul Patrol kept everyone cheering.

This year you've got talent but not necessarily entertainment. Simon alluded to that with his critique of Carly - "You don't look like a star." No one seems to have a sparkling, engaging personality - except maybe Jason and he just has everyone wondering if he's stoned.

[retrokitten]

I agree. I thought that was the most fun season, too.

[vollmond]

Do you think so? I thought the best season was with Pickler, Daughtry, Elliot, Hicks and McPhee.
What a fun year that was! What does everyone else think?

Most entertaining by far. Don't forget Bucky was a part of that season too.

[Captain Beyond]

I have to totally disagree with you there. If season 4 had been trying out with this season's contestants the majority of season 4 would not have made it to the show. Besides Daughtry and Mcphee the rest would have be sitting the season out. JMHO.

Vocally this season is killing any past season. These guys and girls are really singing and singing well. Hey I am not a big fan of pop but these people are really impressing me big time with their vocal skills. As far "Idol Gives Back" last year I thought Kelly C. was awesome with Jeff Beck doing a blues thing for a change it shows she a good range. Her voice gets stronger it seems with time.