American Idol 2008--Live Thread

americanidol.com ^ | 1-14-08

[silent_jonny]

Did you have a McDonaldland by you as a kid? It was so much better then the stupid playland.

LOL! Memories :)

I should have said Burger King's play area. They had one before the local McDonalds. All I remember about that were splinters, sharp corners and a disclaimer sign (placed at kids' eye level) that said Burger King wasn't responsible for injuries in the play area :)

[silent_jonny]

he's never gonna catch up! ;-)

Hey, I'm here. 57 minutes after you posted ;)

[Senator Goldwater]

This year’s crop is definitely better than last years, although that isn’t saying much.

The Australian guy, the dreadlock guy, the sixteen year old kid and the first guy were the only memorable ones.

Tonight, the Irish girl [although a dreadful number], the Carrie lookalike, the two black girls singing white rock songs, and the Filipino girl were the best among the females.

[silent_jonny]

We need to take up a “Silent_Jonny DSL Fund.”

Silent_Jonny is not amused! :)

And DSL isn't going to help me read any faster ;)

[TonyWpi]

Good point.

I just finished watching the show (fast forwarding commercials rules!!)

I liked Kady, Alaina, Revelle?, and Syesha.

Didn’t like Joanne and Nurse Ratchett.

I think Joanne, Amy or Brooke will end up going home.

Too bad because Amy’s so hot my screen fogs up.

[silent_jonny]

I love how it’s in the middle of our posts talking about him and he didn’t even notice. LOL!!

;)

[silent_jonny]

I'm voting for Amanda (04), Brooke (06), Asia (09), Ramiele (10), and Syesha (11).

Good choices. Amanda would be the only one I would be motivated to vote for tonight.

[TonyWpi]

I thought that Carly chick sang well but I just can’t get over her “skankiness.” Ewwww....

I need a shot of penicillin after watching her.

[silent_jonny]

The media is just itching to take down McCain. That makes me want to puke.

Well ... That's why they chose him as our nominee :-/

[Ciexyz]

A Connie Francis b**ch slap to the chick who sang so flat on Where the Boys Are.

[silent_jonny]

We’re talking about him and he’s telling someone to spank him!

You're breaking my spirit!

There ... my spirit is broken.

;)

[TonyWpi]

The NY Slimes “hit piece” on McAmnesty could actually help him because it will “piss off” the conservatives and make them (heck...us) rally around him.

[silent_jonny]

Where the boy’s are?? Should be “where the notes are!”

LOL!

[silent_jonny]

:)

[silent_jonny]

5. Kady Malloy - Groovy Kind of Love - Totally Disagree with Simon. I thought this was an amazing vocal performance. Perfect tone, exceptional quality. BUT - BORING SONG!

I thought she was better than what the judges said, but it was a dull song.

I am sure VFTW will pick one of them

I think they picked Amy Davis, but it means nothing. VFTW has no impact on Idol at all. They're all talk.

[silent_jonny]

Best 24 so far?? Not a chance.

I'm happy with "better 24 than last year", which it is.

[silent_jonny]

I need a shot of penicillin after watching her.

LOL!

I like Carly, but I get that feeling too.

[ChocChipCookie]

Jordin went to our church before she won Idol, and our pastor recently said that she has had many opportunities to witness and live out her Christian beliefs. She’d be someone to remember in your prayers whenever you think of her.

[peggybac]

Absolutely. Thanks.

[Lijahsbubbe]

I'm guessing (from the way she looks) that she hasn't heard many negative comments in her life. Tonight she got three in a row. On national TV.

DEATH GLARE! :)

Exactly! LOL!