Posted on 10/06/2006 8:58:56 PM PDT by Freep EE
Tigh took it too far. That's what Tigh does though, he's a man of extremes (thus the alcoholism, and the devout love for the psycho wife, he just can't do anything half way). The first suicide bombing, which targeted only Cylon colaborators, was OK. But when he decided the marketplace filled with random civilians was a valid target he went too far down the slippery slope.
I commented based on the supposition that the post suggests getting emotional and raising some action because of the viewer's interpretation of an episode. There are some of us who choose to not watch BSG and stated such in the hope that might calm the viewer's "boggle." :)
I'm not sure what you mean by that.
2) Why would Admiral Adama listen to the Pres-elect after the outgoing Pres raise the (unproven) charge that he was with Cyclons at Caprica? Civilian rule / military rule depends on how active the battlefield is. Here a Cylon suspect wants to put all of humanity's eggs in one basket and he defers? They's have been better off with the first Admiral.
Adama is foresquare against the concept of Martial Law. Remember how well it worked when Tighe was in charge? Remember, Adama insisted that Roslyn give up the presidency when it became apparant that she tried to steal the election. He has principals, and will live with them, even at great cost. Remember his speech during the decommisioning ceremony during the original mini-series: Something along the lines of "Do we deserve to survive?"
3) Why was there still people who wanted to go to only one planet when the news was that the Cylons had vacated the original colonies they called home?
Would you really want to go back to your home, on the word of the enemy saying "opps! my bad!" Remember, the Cylons showed that they had the ability to exterminate the human race, and nearly did it once. Would you really want to go back?
Why did the Cylons come back after detecting a nuclear detonation when that was set off by model 6 who would have downloaded again and told them she did it?
She couldn't have downloaded: Remember that at that point, the cylon "resurection ship" had been destroyed.
Mark
Then why are you reading this thread? Just to post you aren't interested?
About the only show I saw that was able to pull off a kick butt woman superior was Babylon 5's Ivanonva. Unlike Starbuck, she was a likeable character as well.
ST TNG did a pro abort episode as well. A planet had a population whose genetic diversity was so low that they stole DNA from the Enterprise officers. After discovering that they had identical clones of themselves, Riker took a phaser to them, pompously intoning "we have the right to control our own bodies" or some similar nonsense. The point of the episode was so transparent and so brutally handled that it might well have had the opposite effect of what the writers intended.
Aside from several episodes like these, I liked TNG. I thought (unlike many) that Patrick Stewart played a good role as the captain.
TNG episodes that you can safely skip are:
-any episode having Deanna Troi's mom in it
-any where the holideck goes beserk (they used that plot just several times too many)
-The one where Worf joins a group of fundamentalists (who are trying to keep the galaxy from having fun, of course)
Re: why No 6 didn't download after nuking Cloud 9, I knew that was the point about the resurrection ship but apparently the Cylons could download on New Caprica. Guess that's a distance thing made anew when they came back?
I appreciate Adm Adama's principles, but if he had reason to suspect that the Pres-elect was a tool and the move to New Caprica foolhardy, he should have maintained defence of his ships. I didn't buy that people would just give up space entirely like that. If you distrust Cyclons enough to avoid the other colonies why think that the new world would be different?
Both Starbuck and Roslyn have character and they are both tough.
Being somewhat sci-fi fan, I was interested. However, if there is a sign on all posts that say "only like-minded people reply", please direct me to that sign.
she did have a nice body... :D and that now leaves me with Sam Carter...(although she may be showing signs of rust... )
I'm not sure if the second photo is really her. The site it came from says it is.
yea the second one is her, www.skins.be has some more of her "amanda tapping" ***beware that site has some naughty pictures ads and such*** but has some nice wallpapers also...
My opinion. Agree, disagree, makes no matter to me.
Hey you can post all you want that you aren't interested in the show on a thread about the show. Go right ahead.
I saw the episode and had the same reaction. I wrote a letter of colplaint to the President of NBC/UNIVERSAL and you might want to as well. He is:
Mr. Randy Falco
President and Chief Operating Officer
NBC Universal Television Group
In a word, it's just a TV show.
And considering that in the long run, political ideologies both sides of the spectrum have been hammered by BSG, I don't have a problem with it.
Then again, if you're that torqued off by it, your television set's remote control has this wonderful button marked "Off."
But don't presume to think for me, nor designate what is "good and proper" to watch.
Just damn.
If you want on the list, FReepmail me. This IS a high-volume PING list...
I don't even watch this show. I saw part of the pilot and turned it off.
He is not. He's just saying he isn't going to watch it anymore and wants us to spread the word that blowing themselves up to fight the evil Cylons isn't OK, which no one else is obliged to do.
Just a harmless advice in my opinion. :-)
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.