[ladyinred]

I am also nervous about Carrie tonight after the way she was bad mouthed by the so called judges last night. She is fantastic, has wonderful talent, and is an American Idol in my mind no matter what happens tonight! So is Anthony, who is a equally talented, but doesn't have much chance with Randy and Paula, who seem to be extremely biased against him! Sigh. I will never let myself get caught up in this show again! LOL

[bootless]

I skipped through my tape from last night just now - lots of work - and I thought both of Anthony's songs were very strong. I was very surprised at Paula's less-than-enthusiastic response to him. He approached early- to mid-season Clay on his first song, and she gave his performance a very flat review. I don't know what she heard, honestly.