I skipped through my tape from last night just now - lots of work - and I thought both of Anthony's songs were very strong. I was very surprised at Paula's less-than-enthusiastic response to him. He approached early- to mid-season Clay on his first song, and she gave his performance a very flat review. I don't know what she heard, honestly.
Anthony doesn't have "it".
Agreed, Paula doesn't seem to have "it" for Anthony like she does some of the others. This is just so nerve wracking!