American Idol 2005--Live Thread

3-15-05

[silent_jonny]

AMERICAN IDOL 2005
LIVE THREAD

[texasflower]

No I had never heard that song before last night. He was pretty bad last night.

It was tonight's performance that I sort of liked.

[TheMom]

You really should not insult dead flies, their unborn may come after you. *shudder*

[Feiny]

It is pretty funny....I hate Scott & it makes me giggle that folks are doing that.

[beandog]

Really ticks me off that the're doing this. We're just going to have to do a better job of voting to counteract what they're doing.

[TonyWpi]

My list: (of the balance)

1) Carrie
2) Bo
3) Anthony
4) Vonzell

I won't even put Slingblade on the list.

[texasflower]

Yeah, the kick is pretty silly. I like Scott, but it is definitely time for him to go.

He gave his best performances in the first few weeks. He's getting worse every week.

Like voice fatigue or something. George Huff did the same thing last year. By the end, he sounded awful.

[silent_jonny]

Freepers we must unite to vote next week for someone other than Scott. We have to beat these unruly voters who are voting for the worst to win. Unless we do the world will have to listen to terrible singing and all will be wrong with the world.

HAAAAAHAAAAHAAAAA!

[no more apples]

Is it my computer or FR that's slow tonight?

[beandog]

I hope you're right.

[rampage8]

I'm no Constantine fan, but I really can't beleive he was booted. The last five Idols are pretty plain-Jane, so what's the excitement any more? He was the only one who was fun to watch, in a sort of "oh my god, how can he be so cheesey" way. I just may miss all the smoldering!

I guess Bo is psyched though.

[Happygal]

I just logged onto the end of this thread.

Bo is still there right? (Haven't seen the show in Ireland for the last two weeks, because I'm appearing on stage myself this week in Sweeney Todd...so don't have time for TV)

[TonyWpi]

You're right...this "Stacked" show is really, really bad.

[texasflower]

I agree that Anthony is a little vanilla as you said. He's only 19 though and I think he can be taught some better performance skills.

Maybe he will really come out with something bold next week.

[twin2]

I agree...o.k. next week better be the week that slingblade leaves or I swear I'm not watching anymore (well maybe I'll watch a little, alright the whole thing, but that's it!)

[YaYa123]

It would be worth millions in CD sales and concerts if Anthony and Carrie were the top two. Did you notice what a cute couple they are? And how refreshing!! Both of them are really fine, natural singers. They don't seem to have wierd hang-ups, inflated egos, or troubled pasts. Two wholesome, fresh faced kids.

[texasflower]

I agree that Anthony is a little vanilla as you said. He's only 19 though and I think he can be taught some better performance skills.

Maybe he will really come out with something bold next week.

[silent_jonny]

It was tonight's performance that I sort of liked.

Yeah, he did do a better job tonight. He wasn't trying so hard.

[TonyWpi]

I always liked George Huff. He seemed like a "regular guy."

Scott is the Jazmine of last year. But at least Jazmine was "eye candy."

[texasflower]

Excellent assessment.

[Netizen]

I think he has as many fans as anti-fans.

I think he gets the votes from some of the older people that are not into country or rock. And that could be a large base. Add to that the votefortheworst site and he could be hard to beat. I bet the people at votefortheworst are haveing aball right about now! lol I like it!