American Idol 2005--Live Thread

3-15-05

[silent_jonny]

AMERICAN IDOL 2005
LIVE THREAD

[msp2004]

Well, I'm in shock. Night all!

[TheMom]

Charity or community service? ;-)

[Feiny]

Only 22 hours left....that is the last time I moon a cop.

[beandog]

If Scott wins it'll sure be the end of the show for me. I really don't think that's going to happen. I know think it's going to be between Carrie and Bo.

[Netizen]

He sounded pretty good and didn't use the creepy faces.

It's like the facade fell off and he returned to normal. imho

Notice how this was a real SHOCKER and yet AI didn't hype the show like they did with Nadia?

[no more apples]

Phew! I'm starting to recover. My daughter called that one - I thought for sure Slingblade was gone. I think my fack is only pink now.

[silent_jonny]

how much worse does psycho have to get to get voted off.

Well in Slingblade's defense, Lt. Dan was TERRIBLE last night, even worse than Scott's off-key caterwauling. But I'm shocked that Lt. Dan is gone (or should I say pleasantly surprised ;)

[gigi]

Wow! I'm shocked and pissed that Scott is still there. I have never voted for Lt. Dan but I'm tired of seeing better singers get voted off and Scott stays.

[texasflower]

So am I. I LOVE Anthony. He's my favorite.

[Netizen]

I am THRILLED Anthony didn't get the boot!

I like him, too and wouldn't mind if he won, even though I am rooting for Carrie.

[Feiny]

I missed the show last night because an old friend dropped in from out of town & having drinks with her was much more important ...but I did listen to the songs online.....Lt. Dan sounded bad....actually I thought they all sucked last night.

[TheMom]

Damn female cops, they have not sense of humor!

[silent_jonny]

I actually enjoyed this performance of Constantine's and not just because it was the last one.

Have you ever heard the original version by Nickleback? It was so much better than Lt. Dan's version. The song didn't fit him at all, IMO.

[texasflower]

It's like the facade fell off and he returned to normal

Yes, that's probably it. I am thrilled that Anthony will have at least another week. He's really starting to relax and put out some good performances.

[EmilyGeiger]

No but he did the creepy kicking! :0) Scott should have been the one to go. Freepers we must unite to vote next week for someone other than Scott. We have to beat these unruly voters who are voting for the worst to win. Unless we do the world will have to listen to terrible singing and all will be wrong with the world.

[b9]

I love FR. I get the results 3 hours early.
Me, too.
I can't believe Slingblade didn't go home.

Well, think of it as hero worship.
He doesn't have a single appealing quality
and when he belts those songs, it's like the shock
of hearing opera from a frog.

I think he has as many fans as anti-fans.

[TonyWpi]

I just checked out "votefortheworst.com" and these loser are all celebrating.

They're about as intellegent as a dead fly.

[Netizen]

I used to like Vonzell...but she kinda pissed me off tonight. When she was "safe," she looks at Anthony and Lt. Dan with an "I'm better than you" look.

I don't care for her or most of the songs she does BUT, try to not be hard on her. We don't know their relationship. The guys all are close right now and we don't know what kind of good natured ribbing goes on off camera. It might have just been a 'see there it wasn't me after all' type of thing that friends do.

[silent_jonny]

Keep ice on that fack!

[Feiny]

Anthony is very vanilla. His voice is good, but I wouldn't buy his cd's. He is bland....maybe he can get a little fierceness & move up a notch.