Posted on 12/17/2003 10:06:13 AM PST by HairOfTheDog
Beyond this point there be spoilers!
Like spoilers? – Keep reading!
Don't want spoilers? – Click HERE and don't look back!
... maybe Gollum's connection to it made him that tough to kill. My best try.
How long would it take thar rock to become a frying pan -- to say nothing of (again) the rising heat?
I had the same issues. But, I've suspended disbelief so far...
Otherwise, great movie, tho I feel strangely let down. Maybe because it's the end. Perhaps the extended DVD will help.
I know where and when to go to avoid the crowds, so I hit the 3:30 PM showing in a theater that was maybe 1/3 full. That helps avoid the annoyances, but I didn't get much audience reaction either.
I have just a couple of nits to pick, mostly what has been said above but I'll add a couple.
1. The music was suitably Wagnerian, but I felt in many places that it was overwhelmed by the sheer noise of everything else going on. This is the classical music lover in me reacting. I bet most viewers wouldn't have noticed it or cared.
2. I didn't like the way the ring ended up in the lava. It's a wonderful build-up in the book the way Frodo uses the power of the ring to curse Gollum to be thrown into the Crack of Doom if he tries to hurt Frodo again, but we don't fully realize what Frodo did until it actually happens. I don't see why that couldn't have worked just as well in the film.
Oh well, there's the extended DVD late next year.
Niggles: I agree with several already cited and won't repeat. The character of Gandalf was considerably reduced from Tolkien's description. The character of the hobbits upon returning to the Shire is quite altered from the book--neglecting the major deletion of the Scouring. Frodo is nowhere near withdrawn and ill enough. Sam, Merry, & Pippin are all too introspective. They each become major dignitaries and personalities in the novel (& appendices).
The two most difficult elements to pull off from the books were the Ents and the Army of the Dead. The first PJ did brilliantly, the latter was not so successful.
See the movie by all means, but if you haven't yet done so, please read the books.
I think I might have forgotten to breathe during that segment! It was just outstanding!
Yeah, we missed the lady who talks a lot in the Houses of Healing!
I think I'm getting it for Christmas! ;o)
One thing that was too bad was that they started Annie Lenox's song somewhat into the credits, and many had left the theater and probably never heard it. It is such a gorgeous song, and it made me start crying again! And I love how they showed the charcoal sketches of each actor's character during the credits. They even showed SEAN BEAN!!!
Oh yeah, Ioreth! I love it when Aragorn tells her to "run as quick as your tongue and get some kingsfoil."
The Shelob scene was completely horrifying, especially to this arachnaphobic hobbit.
DANG!! We didn't get either one of those!!
Dang it, I have always been a credit-stayer, but since the others in my party weren't, I left with them. Well, I must say that Hair ~is~ going to stay through the credits with me at least once!
Yeah... I enjoy these movies more after knowing what changes to expect.
...and teenage boys laughing at innappropriate times and making stupid comments (e.g. "I thought he liked guys" when Sam marries Rosie.) didn't improve the experience. People also complained about the length during the epilogues... Why couldn't they just shut-up and leave?
Usually the midnight crowds are full of serious fans. :-( Trilogy Tuesday must've depleted our ranks at the midnight shows.
I look forward to the day when I own a nice home theater. I love these movies and love watching them on the big screen... but I hate theater crowds.
This is a wonderful movie, in so many ways! Just outstanding! I wanted the whole story to just go on forever! While Jackson has to delete or change some things from the books, he does capture the spirit and the imagination of the books so beautifully!
This is an uplifting story about courage, loyalty, friendship, hope, temptation. It is a story of big things--war, death--and of little things--daily vocation, doing your duty. There is feeling and warmth and emotion to this epic tale with big battle scenes. There is so much here to marvel at and mull over.
Someone loses a finger
Where's that nine finger song?
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.