Posted on 03/06/2021 6:16:11 AM PST by NOBO2012
I couldn’t sleep last night, which is no different than most nights except that instead of laying in the dark I perused the offerings of Stars On Demand and selected Good Will Hunting, the 1997 Ben Affleck/Matt Damon written movie that won wild acclaim at the time but I’d never seen. It was awful with a capital A.
Despite all the acclaim it is a schlocky piece of badly written, overacted tripe which nevertheless kept me company for an hour and half of wokeness. I can’t help but feel my time would have been better spent watching the Friday-up-all-night Diners, Drive-ins and Dives marathon.
Very early on in the movie we are exposed to the protagonist's (Will Hunting played by Matt Damon) genius and wisdom in this exchange with his therapist, played by Robin Williams:
Will: "A History of the United States, Volume I." If you want to read a real history book, read Howard Zinn's "A People's History of the United States." That book will knock you on your ass.
Sean: How about Noam Chomsky's "Manufacturing Consent?"
“Historians may well view it as a step toward a coherent new version of American History.” That’s the ticket.
And with that one scene this ridiculously overrated 25 year old movie shows us how the fire of today’s woke culture was initially stoked by classroom indoctrination and then insidiously reinforced by cultural outlets like movies.
Interesting side note: Ben Affleck and Matt Damon were neighbors with Howard Zinn before they wrote their Oscar winning script. So in a way the scene was simply product placement for Zinn’s A People’s History of the United States. It represented a construct the naïve 20-something boys already firmly ascribed to: the alternate history of the U.S. relying on anti-American narratives, bereft of mitigating historical context and committed to presenting the story of America as an evil history of western-white-male-racism-paternalism-and-imperialism. The fact that it was written by a guy in the neighborhood who supported Mao, Castro and other mass-murdering commie thugs was just a bonus. And with their Oscar success that one throw-away line in the movie helped transform Zinn’s alternate history of America into a cultural icon. That’s the power and the glory of Hollywood.
Several years later David Chase worked Zinn’s American Manifesto into his hugely popular HBO show, The Sopranos, albeit from a rather different mindset. Keep in mind that Chase cast the rather dim Anthony Jr as “the clueless asshole of the family, an obvious unworthy future mob boss that was Tony's burden as a father to endure.” So you can interpret any of his dialogue as the expression of something Chase considers stupid.
This New York Post Obit of Zinn is rather fair and balanced:
Zinn ransacked the past to find alternative models for future struggles. That, of course, is not the job of the historian but of the propagandist.
Like Zinn’s book Good Will Hunting is mind-numbingly superficial, naïve and sophomoric. Don’t waste your time.
The next time I can’t sleep I’ll just look around to see if I can find a Piglet to snuggle.
Posted from: MOTUS A.D.
I watched about 20 minutes and turned it off. I am glad to find out I am not alone. Our culture is doomed!
You went through all that trouble to complain about a movie on an online forum? Friend...its not the movie thats the reason that you feel bothered.
“It was awful with a capital A”
There is no accounting for taste.
Yes, it's doomed all right. Doomed because the movie accurately depicts the politics of the Boston academic world even then.
Again I AM qualified to judge. (I want it well understood that I fled Massachusetts in 1977, never to return.)
A very good friend recently revealed to me that he actually took Zinn's course at B.U., but (he now claims) it was only because he want to get into Zinn's daughter's....aaaah....knickers. Apparently she was quite a looker.
“You went through all that trouble to complain about a movie on an online forum? Friend...its not the movie thats the reason that you feel bothered.”
I appreciate the movie reviews that get posted here.
I had heard this movie mentioned a few times over the last few weeks, and was thinking about watching it. Looks like the author of this review did me a favor.
“initially stoked by classroom indoctrination and then insidiously reinforced by cultural outlets like movies”
. . . and this is something you just now discovered?
It’s been that way since the beginning. The ironic part of your screed is that Chomsky’s work tells all about it.
Take a look at Cass Sunsteins’s “Nudge” and you see the modern version. FWIW - add in Sunstein’s other half, Samantha Power and her 2003 essay “How to kill a Country” and you can see the Obama playbook writ large.
Price of Admission - Free
All of the Hollywood productions are slop. They’re nothing but left wing propaganda. I spend my time learning on YouTube where the possibilities are endless.
“...Damon (or rather his voice coaches) got the working-class Boston accent exactly right.”
As a Boston native I totally agree. Perfect. And we are fussy about it. Every time Ray Donovan pronounced “sure” as “shaw” I wanted to punch him in the head. Alec Baldwin butchered the accent twice, once in The Departed and once in that godawful bomb squad movie which I watched being filmed in Copley Square from the Hancock Tower. That’s some Boston right there. Looking down on helicopters was a first.
This movie is ancient.
You might as well do a review of a movie from the 40’s.
I enjoyed that movie - although some of it is overwrought and some just falls flat. It’s certainly not an infomercial for Zinn’s crappy book (nor Chomsky’s). It has the only Ben Affleck performance I actually like.
Begone, troll. Anything that pimps for Zinn and Chomsky is explicitly leftist.
Begone, Troll.
ok i see how you are. how about you show me and everyone here (and please stay on topic) how the movie Good Will Hunting is only leftist propaganda.
Begone, Troll.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.