Skip to comments.Bassam Tibi: Euro-Islam Doesn’t Have a Chance
Posted on 08/13/2016 5:50:37 PM PDT by annalex
The following essay by the Syrian-German Islamic reformer Bassam Tibi was originally published by Die Welt. Many thanks to Brunhilde for the translation:
Young men who bring a culture of violence with them
by Bassam Tibi
The events in Cologne were just a prelude: Many Arab migrants bring very misogynistic social values to Germany. That makes it almost impossible for them to be integrated. A guest commentary.
Is there any connection between the attacks on New Years Eve in Cologne and the situation in Syria? The answer is: Yes, there is a connection and the common denominator is violence against women.
Many of my German discussion partners do not seem to understand the violence that is directed against women in a oriental patriarchal culture. In the orient, a woman is not considered an entity, but an object of a mans honour. The violation of a woman is not viewed only as a sexual act and crime against the woman herself, but more as an act of humiliation of the man to whom she belongs.
In this barbaric war in Syria, that completely erroneously is called a civil war (no citizens, but rather ethno-religious collectives, are fighting each other in it), the Shiite-Alawite soldiers of the Syrian army rape women of the Sunni opposition as a method of warfare.
With rape, these Alawites are seeking to dishonour the men of the Sunni opposition. The Sunni rebels for their part do the same with Alawite women. It is a war of all against all with women as pawns.
Cologne was not an isolated case
As a Syrian from Damascus, I am astonished at the ignorance and naïveté of the Chancellor and her defence minister, who believe that they can end the war with conferences in Geneva and Munich. But this war should be categorized as a protracted conflict that will be with us for many years. It is a type of war that I call an irregular not state-run war.
Among the war refugees, there are not only victims of violence but also many perpetrators, and even numerous Islamists. Added to that is the fact that these predominantly young men aged 14 to 20 bring with them the culture of violence, including against women, from the Near East to Germany. New Years Eve in Cologne is just a demonstration of that, and no isolated case as our politicians like to pretend in order to downplay the significance of the matter.
Independent of the war, the image of women in the Arabic-oriental culture is patriarchal, even comprehensively inhuman. This image of women must not be tolerated in Europe under the mantle of respect for other cultures.
And for the Arab man, the sexual violence is not just about the sexual attraction of the European woman but also about the European man, whose honour he wants to besmirch. And that is what happened in Cologne.
Cologne was just the beginning. If Germany brings in over a million people from the world of Islam and does not fulfil their expectations, we had better be prepared for a few things. From advertisements, all these young men think that they know that every European has a luxury apartment, a car and a pretty blonde; they think that they will get all that too and join in the prosperity.
But when these young men instead end up receiving emergency accommodation in school gyms or sports arenas, they feel like they have been deceived and discriminated against. So they develop a desire for revenge against the European man. The disappointed and enraged Arab men therefore took their revenge in Cologne and Hamburg against German men, represented by their women.
As a Syrian who represents an enlightened Islam and who advocates respect for women, I say: That was a culturally anchored act of revenge. What should be criticized here is not only the much lamented false tolerance, but also the ignorance about other cultures.
The conflict in Syria between Sunnis and Alawites, which has developed into a bloody war, will accompany us for many years to come. The number of the dead meanwhile amounts to about half a million Syrians, among them one hundred thousand Alawites; the rest are Sunnis. This kind of conflict is difficult to resolve. An example of this from the past is the Lebanon conflict between Christians and Muslims that lasted from 1975 to 1990, that is 15 years.
Religion belongs to Allah
In Syria the conflict has a long history. The Syrian capital Damascus is the oldest continuously inhabited city in the world; from 661 to 750 it was the capital of the Omayyad kingdom, that is to say the first imperial Caliphate of Islam that stretched from Spain to western China.
In the late 19th century, Christians and Muslims adopted the European idea of the Nation, in which both had equal rights (therefore different from the Caliphate, where Christians were considered second class believers). Secular pan-Arabism arose from this. After the dissolution of the Ottoman Empire, Syria became a mandate of France from 1920 to 1945, and after that an independent secular republic.
In this secular Syria I was born in 1944 in Damascus, an offspring of the Ashraf aristocratic family Banu al-Tibi. The orientation of our values was: Religion belongs to Allah, but the fatherland belongs to all. Thats what the Sunni majority thought, about 70%, and lived in mutual respect with a large number of religious and ethnic minorities.
Bloody feelings of vengeance
Damascus was a peaceful city with a Christian and a Kurdish quarter. That changed after 1970, when the Alawite-Shiite General Hafiz al-Assad seized power. In the years that followed, he succeeded in filling all key positions in the army and security services with Alawites.
Inspired by the Arab spring of 2011, there was an uprising of the Sunni majority against the Alawite rule from which the current war arose. A bloody line of enmity, laden with a strong desire for revenge, between Sunnis and Alawites characterizes this conflict. Alawites and Sunnis do not have a common future.
Neither regional nor international powers are able to gain control of this conflict. In the Syrian conflict, it is important to understand that Putin is not employing his Russian military power out of sympathy for Assad, but solely in an effort to force the West to recognize Russia as an equal actor. At the Munich security conference in February of 2016, it became clear that Putin had achieved this goal.
The conflict in Syria is illustrative of a continuing process of disintegration of states in the Near East. This is currently also happening in Iraq, Libya, and Yemen. The consequence of this will be that in the coming years, massive demographic avalanches are in store for Europe.
Thanks to the invitation of Chancellor Merkel, Germany is the primary destination of the refugees. But the other Europeans are not playing along. The childrens squabble among all German parties about upper limits and limiting the number shows that German politicians do not understand the dimension of the problems.
Early in 2015 following the murders in Paris, Chancellor Merkel participated in a public demonstration in Berlin shoulder to shoulder with Islam functionaries who vehemently oppose a European Islam, and still she doesnt even know what she is doing. Her Syrian and refugee policies lie along this line.
While German politicians and German Gutmenschen speak about tolerance and the misery of the refugees in a German pathos of the absolute (Adorno), the Islamists laugh contemptuously and call these debates Byzantine blather.
Far and wide no Euro-Islam
The origin of the term is revealing: In the year 1453, the Byzantine capital Constantinople was besieged by an Islamic Ottoman army. During this siege, Byzantine and Christian monks exhausted themselves in debates about magical and religious formulas, despite the seriousness of the situation.
In the same year, 1453, the Islamic Sultan Mehmed II successfully conquered Constantinople with his troops and transformed the city into an Islamic Istanbul. Since that time Islamic historians have therefore called such debates Byzantine blather.
As a Syrian from Damascus, I have been living in Germany since 1962, and I know: Patriarchally minded men from a misogynistic culture cannot be integrated. A European, civil Islam that the Islamic functionaries in these parts have rejected as Euro-Islam, would be the alternative. At the present time, it doesnt have a chance. My teacher Max Horkheimer called Europe an island of freedom in an ocean of dictatorships. Today I see this freedom endangered.
We publish this text with the kind permission of the publishing house Kiepenheuer & Witsch. It is a preview of the book by Alice Schwartzer, The Shock New Years Eve in Cologne, to be released in May.
Bassam Tibi, 72, is a Political Scientist Emeritus at the University of Göttingen. He arrived in Germany at the age of 18 from Syria.
If you want to be on this right wing, monarchy, paleolibertarianism and nationalism ping list, but are not, please let me know. If you are on it and want to be off, also let me know. This ping list is not used for Catholic-Protestant debates; all confessions are welcome.
But it’s wonderful. The third world violent muslims don’t have to integrate. Europeans will integrate to their new invaders.
Outstanding post and thanks!
So these refugees feel entitled to the wealth of their host countries and when they don’t get it they rape the women to besmirch the honor of the men because they believe men essentially “own” women.
Even if they don’t believe these women are owned by a man, they will feel that they own them and therefore should be raped.
Annalex, this is a great read.
Eight century people with cell phones and porn and blonde Germany girls you have a problem. This is the third time in one hundred years that Germany has blown up Europe.
That remains to be seen. I’m still not sure who will be running the concentration camps I sadly see in Europe’s future.
Bump. Very interesting essay, not that it will mean anything to our idiot Islam-friendly SJW Leftists.
'The revolution won't happen with guns, rather it will happen incrementally, year by year, generation by generation. We will gradually infiltrate their educational institutions and their political offices, transforming them slowly into Marxist entities as we move to universal egalitarianism." - Max Horkheimer
Bassam Tibi is correct of course, but Merkel is too stupid to listen let alone understand the realities that he speaks. Europe is doomed if they do not change leadership, and soon.
That seems to rebut the entire piece; however, Germany was Karl’s birthplace and his spawn already inhabit the halls of Europe. Europe’s socialism is in its final cycle which only adds another complication to an intractable problem.
The author of this piece seems to offer a reasonable analysis of the current “refugee” situation with a unique perspective. There exists today an attempt to rewrite history and create a Golden Age of Islam out of whole cloth—portraying Medieval Muslims as innovative custodians of culture when, in fact, nothing could be further from the truth. The few who appreciated science and culture stole the work of more advanced civilizations whom they had conquered and even then worked in defiance of the Islamic faith.
Yet there was a Golden Age for many Muslims, and that was a period in the late nineteenth century and lasted until the latter twentieth. The brief age of secular Muslim states flourished when Turkish, Lebanese, Iranian and Syrian leaders attempted to join modern society. While not popular democratic states and many flirted with socialism, these were nations struggling to enter the twentieth century with all her complications. They failed and are failing and our feeble attempts at resuscitation have only furthered that decline.
The true irony in the situation when Westerners call for Islamic reform. The Islamic Reformation has already occurred, and its greatest adherents are known as ISIS. The secularists and minorities have been slaughtered and displaced by Islamic fundamentalists, and yet it is those very fundamentalists who comprise the bulk of the “refugees!”
These people cannot and will not assimilate. They are incapable of reason and inculcated with hatred for their hosts.
Inviting such a force into your country is to ensure generations of violence. The only question that remains is why so many leader do so. Those who grant these leaders charitable intent are much more charitable than I.
Too bad Max, the 'sophisticated' elite, getting his wish and running socialism at full bore, thinking that he was on an 'island of freedom in an ocean of dictatorships,' isn't around to drown in his miscalculating lies.
You are welcoome. Thank you for reading.
The point is that the rape of Cologne was an act of war, not a bump on the road to Arab assimilation, and not a young body’s need for sexual gratification.
For a primitive mind, there is no better statement of military victory than “We came into your land and raped your women”.
Gates of Vienna is generally a very good resource.
The left is not Islam-friendly, it is Christianity-hostile.
Your conversation raises a good question. What is the relationship between the modern European Left, Marxism, and Islam?
All three hate Christianity. That is what unites them; so when one of the three does something hurtful to the Christian West, the other two assist. Islam has energy that others lack; so the Left makes up a legal environment with unenforceable national borders, and the USSR gave them weapons and a secular philosophy, which the governments of the last half of 20 century could attach to Islam.
But they also hate each other. The Left dreams of peaceful Islam and hates the violent misogynistic reality of it. The Marxists hate any religion, especially one inspiring millions. The Left and the Marxism oppose each other on the usefulness and desirability of democracy. Merkel, for example, is no Marxist: she saw Marxism in operation in East Germany and did not like it.
I don’t think our enemy can be properly seen as a single entity.
Social Justice Warrior
And the Left is Islam friendly if they perceive it helps them against the Right.
Ping. Worthwhile, as are the comments at Gates of Vienna. Didn’t one of your essays make it there?
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.