Replies

I have also read parts of this author's book, "On Healing the East-West Split." Interesting perspective, especially as we find ourselves here on FR not only defending against fundamentalists but also our orthodox brethren lately.

Bump for later re-reading -- there's too much here for one sitting!

Great article. I may have to read his book.

Yes, sometimes the attacks on Catholics from Orthodox on FR are more virulent than any others. They say the most appalling things!

I think part of this has to do with the fact that many of them are converts to the Orthodox Church, and in many cases, are former Catholics. There's a bit of personal stuff going on there, I suspect.

The Orthodox churches in America are increasingly made up of converts. I think the children of ethnic Orthodox often see the churches as too ethnic, and become Protestants, if anything.

I spent a number of years in a heavily Orthodox environment, however, and while I love the Liturgy and the emphasis of the theology, I think it's a church - well, lots of churches - with many problems. The fact that a number of these churches are not even in communion with each other, for example, seriously undermines their claim to be the "Church," except in the most mystical sense!

However, it's almost impossible to discuss this with Orthodox persons. They become nearly irrational. I think this is at least partly because they know, deep down inside, that Orthodox problems won't be solved until they are reunited with Rome.

I agree that there are many, many problems in doing this, and there is much to be worked out. The example of the limping relationship that Eastern rite Catholic Churches have with Rome is not encouraging. But it can be done, and I think it's going to have to happen for the good of all. After all, the Catholic Church also would certainly benefit from this infusion of good theology and splendid liturgy. Perhaps this is part of God's plan: both sides have to realize that they need each other.

Thanks! hehe...did you wear flame retardent before posting?