I agree: "charisma" means gift, which means it is free, though sometimes two words can reinforce a meaning, yet I never got in this debate. Thus I think you meant to respond to someone. "The rest of your post is simply more recourse to parroting propaganda in lie of an actual argument" refers to the Catholic adversary, not you, but whom I copied in to ping those who were engaged in debate with her(?).
Basically it was a grammar thing and it evolved into a religious thing; I see the words “free gift” on many adverts and was just questioning the redundancy of using free attached to gift.