2012 Presidential voting D 49% R 48%
2018 midterm elections. D 50% R 49%
Roman Catholics are not helping the Republic.
Barky won the popular by 4 in 2012. Barky won the Catholic vote by 1 (at least according to this poll data). Therefore the Catholic vote moved right after 2008. In 2008 the Catholic vote and national vote were BOTH at about barky by 6.
But then you forget that most Jews are clustered in the highly liberal big cities.
If one looked at Jews from rural areas, they vote like the people from rural areas
So, the religious angle is one, well, angle. There are a number of other issues at play.