Free Republic
Browse · Search
Religion
Topics · Post Article

Skip to comments.

Ask the Rabbi: Why Don’t Jews Believe in Original Sin?
PJ Media ^ | 04/19/2018 | Avner Zarmi

Posted on 04/19/2018 8:45:00 AM PDT by SeekAndFind

This is a delicate question, as it exposes one of the fundamental differences between the Christian outlook and the Jewish one.

As far as I understand the Christian concept, it runs something like this: Ever since the expulsion of the first man and woman from Eden, the world has been “fallen” and all subsequent human beings have been born inherently sinful, guilty from the moment of birth as a result of the first man’s disobedience of G-d’s commandment not to eat of the ‘Etz haDa‘ath Tov vaRa -- usually translated “the Tree of the Knowledge of Good and Evil.” The only way to escape condemnation and eternal damnation for this inherently sinful nature is to accept the blood sacrifice of the Christian savior. In this fashion one can gain salvation, purely as an act of Divine grace, without dessert or merit on the part of the human being.

To my mind, there is a basic flaw in this reasoning. Christians often picture Jews as believing in a dour, harshly judgmental “Old Testament” G-d, despite dozens of statements in Tanach (the proper name for what Christians call the “Old Testament”) expressing G-d’s love of Israel and indeed, all humanity. They juxtapose this to the “loving G-d” of the “New Testament.” This invites the question: What about the billions of human beings who were born and lived their lives without knowing anything whatsoever about the Romans’ execution of a carpenter in Judaea some 2,000 years ago? If G-d is indeed rachum vechanun, “merciful and gracious,” as the Bible asserts (cf. Exodus XXXIV ,6), how could He allow such a state of affairs to go on?

This view of an inherently evil world is often expressed in almost Manichaean terms, with the world dominated by an evil being -- “the Devil,” “Satan,” a “fallen angel” -- in opposition to G-d.

So what, in fact, do Jews believe?

Consider the terms tov and ra, conventionally translated, as I wrote before, as “good” and “evil.” At every stage of the world’s creation, G-d pronounced it tov before proceeding to the next stage. On the creation of mankind, He pronounced it tov me’od (“very good”), and there is no indication thereafter that He changed his mind.

Ra does not actually mean “evil” in the English sense of the word. Some glimmering of its actual meaning can be ascertained from some of the other ways that the root is used. For instance, in Psalms II, 9 King David beseeches G-d to deal with his enemies: Tero‘em beshevet barzel (“You should smash them with an iron rod”), or in Isaiah XXIV, 19 the prophet begins his description of an earthquake: Ra’o hithro‘a‘a ha’aretz ("the Earth is completely shaken”). From these, we can see that it means something like “unstable, broken, dysfunctional” and therefore “bad.”

Human beings come into this world innocent of anything, but possessed of a capacity for good (commonly termed the yetzer hatov) as well as a destructive capacity, commonly termed the yetzer hara. The yetzer hara presents all the physical urges, the needs and wants, of the physical body which, like everything else in the physical realm, is subject to entropy -- that is, it wears out and falls apart. But he is also provided with a soul, whose highest purpose is to control those urges and channel them into positive actions.

To this end, children are provided with parents and other mentors, whose job it is to teach them right from wrong and self-control, so that his soul is capable of taking charge and leading a proper, sanctified life. Until that moment when he is capable of taking over, any “sins” that the child commits are the responsibility of the parent.

So when does a Jewish individual begin to sin? At the age of bar or bath mitzva. These terms mean “son or daughter of the commandments” because on reaching that age, they become subject to the 613 commandments in the Torah, and their parents are no longer responsible for their actions. This landmark occurs when a boy is 13 years old and a girl is 12. One of the most emotional moments of the bar mitzva ceremony comes when the boy’s father pronounces the blessing, baruch sheptarani me‘onsho shel ze (“Blessed is He who has exempted me from this one’s punishment”).

What is the Jewish concept of the satan? Well, we agree with the Christians that he is a mal’ach, conventionally translated “angel,” but there’s nothing “fallen” about him. He works for the same Divine Boss as all the other mal’achim. Think of the satan (the word means “adversary”) as the proctor of an exam. The proctor isn’t actively rooting for you to fail the test; to the contrary, he wants you to pass. But he administers a tough test, to be certain that it tests all your capabilities and that you’ve mastered the material, i.e. the life lessons available from one’s parents and other mentors. If you manage to pass the test, no one is happier than the satan.

Of course, to be constantly consciously aware of one’s actions and to control and channel the yetzer hara requires arduous, exhausting effort; most of us stumble somewhere on the path, which is what the term usually translated “sin,” chet, actually means: “to miss a mark or a target.” For this, there is the process called teshuva, roughly “repentance,” literally “return” to the straight and narrow after having erred and strayed from the path.

Because G-d truly is rachum vechanun, erech apayim verav chesed ve’emeth, notzer chesed la’alafim, mose ‘avon vafesha vachata’a vnaqe (“merciful and gracious, long-suffering, great of kindness and trust, keeping kindness for the thousands, bearing iniquity and transgression and sin, and cleansing.” Exodus ibid.).


TOPICS: Judaism; Moral Issues; Theology
KEYWORDS: jews; originalsin; theology
Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first 1-2021-36 next last

1 posted on 04/19/2018 8:45:01 AM PDT by SeekAndFind
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | View Replies]

To: SeekAndFind
If you manage to pass the test, no one is happier than the satan.

I cannot even begin to imagine how to contrast that statement with Isaiah 14:13. The self deceit one must have to look at Satan as your proctor, I cannot conceive of it.
2 posted on 04/19/2018 8:55:17 AM PDT by wbarmy (I chose to be a sheepdog once I saw what happens to the sheep.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: SeekAndFind
What is the Jewish concept of the satan? Well, we agree with the Christians that he is a mal’ach, conventionally translated “angel,” but there’s nothing “fallen” about him.

Jeshua disagrees.

"I beheld Satan as lightning fall from heaven." -Luke 10:18

3 posted on 04/19/2018 9:00:02 AM PDT by rjsimmon (The Tree of Liberty Thirsts)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: SeekAndFind

Joooooz


4 posted on 04/19/2018 9:11:17 AM PDT by wastedyears (Americans are dreamers too.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: SeekAndFind

This Rabbi is a fool. Instead of just stating what Jews believe he starts out by mischaracterizing and denigrating Christianity. How does that help anything?


5 posted on 04/19/2018 9:15:31 AM PDT by Tom in SFCA
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: SeekAndFind
I Peter 4:6 "For this is why the gospel was preached even to those who are dead, that though judged in the flesh the way people are, they might live in the spirit the way God does. (NASB)

They've been provided a chance at salvation as those who believe in Christ after his crucifixion, resurrection and before the judgment.

6 posted on 04/19/2018 9:26:02 AM PDT by rx (Truth Will Out!)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Tom in SFCA

Every single Rabbi I have ever talked to starts the conversation the same way.

They break down first what you hold evident, then they fill in the spaces with their views.

I’m not anti-semitic. It’s just something that people do when they want to convert you to their ways.


7 posted on 04/19/2018 9:28:40 AM PDT by Celerity
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 5 | View Replies]

To: SeekAndFind

Oy-vey. This guy needs to go back to Torah school.


8 posted on 04/19/2018 9:29:00 AM PDT by Gritty-Kitty
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: SeekAndFind
This invites the question: What about the billions of human beings who were born and lived their lives without knowing anything whatsoever about the Romans’ execution of a carpenter in Judaea some 2,000 years ago? If G-d is indeed rachum vechanun, “merciful and gracious,” as the Bible asserts (cf. Exodus XXXIV ,6), how could He allow such a state of affairs to go on?

I once saw an explanation of that, I don't recall where and when or the full text/context of it. It stated that Christ after His death and before the resurrection offered salvation to the souls of those who had not known Him, and those who accepted His sacrifice would be saved. As in life, an evil soul would reject Him, and a sinful but righteous soul (since ALL have sinned) would accept Him.

9 posted on 04/19/2018 9:55:04 AM PDT by JimRed ( TERM LIMITS, NOW! Build the Wall Faster! TRUTH is the new HATE SPEECH.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: SeekAndFind
...“merciful and gracious, long-suffering, great of kindness and trust, keeping kindness for the thousands, bearing iniquity and transgression and sin, and cleansing.”

Loving and forgiving, slow to anger, rich in kindness...partially remembered from a hymn.

10 posted on 04/19/2018 9:58:27 AM PDT by JimRed ( TERM LIMITS, NOW! Build the Wall Faster! TRUTH is the new HATE SPEECH.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: SeekAndFind

This is almost to the level of denying that there is evil in this world.
Let’s look at the book of Job. Was Satan the proctor in an exam. No, Satan wanted Job to fail, to curse G*d and die.


11 posted on 04/19/2018 10:00:09 AM PDT by Fred Hayek (The Democratic Party is now the operational arm of the CPUSA)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: SeekAndFind
“to miss a mark or a target.”

This is what sin meant then, and therefore its real meaning now. Few understands this! Try to understand this if you don't already. REAL-ize this! It's implications are rather profound, especially as it is counter to the collective-agreement-meaning most carry with them when they use the term internally or externally.

It means 'you shot your arrow, and you missed the bulls eye.' Period. Maybe you envisioned a target that was not the target, or maybe you just suck at aiming (bad character), or maybe you just aren't perfect (original sin.) Anything additional including judgement or the tacking on of ancillary attributes such as 'good' or 'bad' is embellishment, narrative, story and hence lies of commission or omission when compared to the truth as it actually is - as God created it - as opposed to the dramatic story in our heads.

Life in a universe that was there before you were, and out of which you are made and hence inherited all its attributes and are connected to all of it, is really quite simple, though I admit it doesn't always appear that way. It is the appearance that is the lie. The appearance is 'The World,' yes it is fallen, but it's not real. The original sin is to mistake The World - the appearance - for 'the world' as it was created, and simply is.

All sins - pride, greed etc. etc. etc. find a common root: The sufferer (and committer) mistakes The World for the world, acts as though The World were the world, and in doing so, shoots off arrows in every crazy direction like a Samurai in an LSD hallucination. His behavior makes no sense to anyone except perhaps his fellows caught up in the same collective hallucination. That is the default state of human existence, and why history, as Steyn has said, is an ongoing cycle of farce followed by farce followed by tragedy.

Satan? He neither cheers the human nor hates the human. He stands by snickering, but not malignantly so. He didn't cause any of it, unless you were to say 'Satan, thy name is ignorance, blindness and delusion - and further - the will to remain so!'

12 posted on 04/19/2018 10:01:14 AM PDT by tinyowl (A is A)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: SeekAndFind

Bookmark


13 posted on 04/19/2018 10:16:03 AM PDT by aquila48
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Fred Hayek

“Let’s look at the book of Job. Was Satan the proctor in an exam. No, Satan wanted Job to fail, to curse G*d and die.”


That is simply not correct. Satan was/is an angel (granted a very high-ranking one) who was created by God - and the express purpose of ANY angel is to do God’s bidding. To think that something created by God to serve Him could disobey, let alone lead an active revolt, let alone succeed for more than literally a single micro-second...that is blasphemy.

No, in the Book of Job, Satan is charged with challenging Job’s faith by every means possible. He/it had the task of being very tough, of stripping away everything that Job knew, had or loved, so as to get to the essential Job. God knew that Job was faithful, but he had to be tested to prove it, and also to serve as a positive example to other people.

By the way, the Jewish concept of Hell is being without God in the World to Come (i.e. the afterlife or Heaven). There is no “Evil Central,” which sits there and plans to do evil and tempt humans...evil is just what our base nature leads us to do, from the standpoint of pure pleasure/self-interest. Having a physical body and physical needs, we are almost constantly tempted to stray from the ideals that God set forth for us...but that temptation is the very purpose of Creation - to allow us to exercise Free Will by having real choices. Without Free Will, there is simply no point to existence.


14 posted on 04/19/2018 10:17:56 AM PDT by Ancesthntr ("The right to buy weapons is the right to be free." A. E. van Vogt)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 11 | View Replies]

To: SeekAndFind

“What about the billions...”

I guess they’d wind up in that Sheol thing. Not so much a “condemnation”, but a lack of salvation according to the new covenant.

Note, “new” implies there was once “old” which also implies some finite amount of elapsed time before everyone gets the memo.

I think the heavenly bean-counters administrated the uninformed souls of this transition period with “purgatory”.


15 posted on 04/19/2018 10:19:22 AM PDT by fruser1
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: rjsimmon

rjsimmon: Jeshua disagrees. “I beheld Satan as lightning fall from heaven.” -Luke 10:18

Luke was following a false Messiah so who cares what he says.


16 posted on 04/19/2018 10:20:51 AM PDT by WisconsinRep
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 3 | View Replies]

To: Celerity
It’s just something that people do when they want to convert you to their ways.

Or maybe it's more that they want to establish a distance -- to make it clear to you that you won't convert them.

Just as Christians often tell Jews where they think they went wrong, Jews do the same thing to Christians.

It may make you bristle if you're not used to it, but I don't think the rabbi overdoes it here.

Also, Judaism has been around for a long time and doesn't always give clear answers.

Sometimes the rabbi's real argument may be with other Jews.

17 posted on 04/19/2018 10:28:07 AM PDT by x
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 7 | View Replies]

To: WisconsinRep
Luke was following a false Messiah so who cares what he says.

Nope. Jesus IS the Messiah. He proved that time and again.

18 posted on 04/19/2018 10:31:13 AM PDT by rjsimmon (The Tree of Liberty Thirsts)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 16 | View Replies]

To: Ancesthntr

So God can never be angry, because He made everything happen, correct?


19 posted on 04/19/2018 10:38:21 AM PDT by ConservativeMind (Trump: Befuddling Democrats, Republicans, and the Media for the benefit of the US and all mankind.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 14 | View Replies]

To: SeekAndFind

It’s been my observation that Jews don’t need original sin to feel guilty, LOL.


20 posted on 04/19/2018 10:48:01 AM PDT by Pearls Before Swine ("Married with children.")
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]


Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first 1-2021-36 next last

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.

Free Republic
Browse · Search
Religion
Topics · Post Article

FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson