[Elsie]

I do not accept your premise.

Then the jury awaits your explanation of what is wrong with it...

All humans; born of normal human parents; are sinners.
Mary was born of normal human parents.
Therefore; she was a sinner.

[omegatoo]

Because not all humans, born of human parents, are sinners. Babies, mentally incapacitated people, etc, are not sinners. Your premise is flawed, therefore what follows is not logically true. It may BE true (I don’t think so), but you cannot prove it by logic.

The scripture ‘all have sinned’ does not define or limit the word ‘all’. You can only do that by inserting words into scripture that are not there. Since we know Jesus did not sin and babies and incapacitated people do not sin, we know there are exceptions to “all”. This statement would then have to be a generalization which cannot be taken literally else it is false, and nothing in the Bible can be false.

Love,
O2