[terycarl]

Unless of course you don't see Joseph and Mary's marriage as being valid.

I have no idea as to what constitutes a valid Jewish marriage.

[Syncro]

You seem to be wrong on all things marriage.

But then you state that all Christians must be Catholics.

Nice to know that you seem to think it is possible that Joseph and Mary didn’t have a “valid” marriage.

You have been saying only Catholic marriages count, Jesus wasn’t a Catholic although you once said he was the first Catholic.

Now he’s Jewish?????

Was that enough question marks to make my question reaaaallll important?????

[Elsie]

Hello!

They were the FIRST Christians; therefore the FIRST Catholics!!