Replies

Please mark this a Catholic Caucus thread.

Wonderful article from Father Rutler. Thanks for posting.

The article does not qualify for a Catholic Caucus because it contrasts been Catholic and non-Catholic belief.

There's another option between "caucus" labels and open threads.

For everyone, I suggest the underused "ecumenical" label--if you are able to follow the instructions. If you're a professing Christian who likes the Bible, I'd say that part of following the instructions is as simple as putting Romans 12:17-21 into practice.

http://freerepublic.com/~religionmoderator/

Religion Forum threads labeled “Ecumenical”

Ecumenical threads are closed to antagonism.

To antagonize is to incur or to provoke hostility in others.
Unlike the “caucus” threads, the article and reply posts of an “ecumenical” thread may discuss more than one belief, but antagonism is not tolerable.
More leeway is granted to what is acceptable in the text of the article than to the reply posts. For example, the term “gross error” in an article will not prevent an ecumenical discussion, but a poster should not use that term in his reply because it is antagonistic. As another example, the article might be a passage from the Bible which would be antagonistic to Jews. The passage should be considered historical information and a legitimate subject for an ecumenical discussion. The reply posts however must not be antagonistic.
Contrasting of beliefs or even criticisms can be made without provoking hostilities. But when in doubt, only post what you are “for” and not what you are “against.” Or ask questions.
Ecumenical threads will be moderated on a “where there’s smoke, there’s fire” basis. When hostility has broken out on an “ecumenical” thread, I’ll be looking for the source.
Therefore “anti” posters must not try to finesse the guidelines by asking loaded questions, using inflammatory taglines, gratuitous quote mining or trying to slip in an “anti” or “ex” article under the color of the “ecumenical” tag.

Please mark this a Catholic Caucus thread.

I think YOU should have done this from the getgo.

Best thing you can do now is to get the WHOLE thread pulled (IIRC)