[af_vet_1981]

Yet your own catechism says it is upon the confession of Peter.

Yes it does, and if you could only read a bit further you would have found it also says Peter is the rock (see post 4813 or read in the Catechism at 552). You were reading in the Catholic Catechism and not some other site, correct ?

[ealgeone]

> Yet your own catechism says it is upon the confession of Peter.<

Yes it does, and if you could only read a bit further you would have found it also says Peter is the rock (see post 4813 or read in the Catechism at 552). You were reading in the Catholic Catechism and not some other site, correct ?

You've got the CCC saying two different things, ECFs with contradictory positions on this, and other issues.

Must be confusing to be a catholic.