[dsc]

“Poor parsing on your part.”

Poor reading on your part.

“Haven’t encountered” is NOT the same as claiming ALL Catholics do such and such.”

I didn’t say “all Catholics.” When I said “Catholics disagree,” that implicitly excludes Catholics who do not disagree and Catholics whose status is unknown. Logic 101.

[Elsie]

When I said “Catholics disagree,” that implicitly excludes Catholics who do not disagree and Catholics whose status is unknown.

No; it does not. Go back to English 101.