“No. You are wrong and Pope Benedict was wrong in giving a pectoral cross to Rowan Williams.”
No, I am absolutely correct: giving someone a pectoral cross as a gift does not mean you recognize someone as a legitimate bishop. The pope may have been wrong in giving it to him, but at this point it would only matter to cranks on the internet.
“Two wrong don’t make a right.”
There was only one possible wrong, so your statement doesn’t even make sense.
No. You said giving a pectoral cross to someone was no different than giving a rosary to someone.
You are wrong, yet you have to the gall to lecture people on “what every Catholic should know”.