Free Republic
Browse · Search
Religion
Topics · Post Article

Skip to comments.

THE PROTESTANT’S DILEMMA BY DEVIN ROSE: A REVIEW
Just a writer, who refuses to typecast his blog by giving it a title ^ | March 18, 2014 | Scott Eric Alt

Posted on 03/19/2014 1:32:10 PM PDT by rwa265

If a Protes­tant look­ing into the claims of Catholi­cism were to ask me, “What one book should I read, where I can find a quick answer to any ques­tion I have?” I would tell him to read Devin Rose’s new book The Protestant’s Dilemma. I would also rec­om­mend this book to Protes­tant apol­o­gists, even those of many years, well-skilled in polemics. It will remind them of the heavy bur­den of proof they face, and the weak­ness of their posi­tion on point after point. The truth may set them free and bring them home too. (It has happened.)

All this may seem like over­state­ment — the oblig­a­tory praise from one Catholic blog­ger to another. But it is not.

Con­sider first the range of issues this book takes up. There are thirty-six chap­ters, each one on a dif­fer­ent topic, from the papacy to sola scrip­tura, from the canon of the Bible to Pur­ga­tory, from con­fes­sion to Eucharist to infant bap­tism. If some­thing about the Catholic Church trou­bles you, this book has the answer. If you think you have found the point on which Catholi­cism fails, this book will show you why it is one more point upon which Protes­tantism fails.

Con­sider also the brevity. The book is just over 200 pages long, which means that Mr. Rose’s answers get to the root of the ques­tion with­out a knot of aca­d­e­mic detail. It is harder to do than it might seem. This is the book of a man who has spent a long time study­ing the ques­tions that divide Protes­tants and Catholics, and who knows how to present his case in a way that is easy for any­one to under­stand. At the same time, the book is use­ful for the pro­fes­sional apol­o­gist, for it recalls his mind to the basics.

(Excerpt) Read more at scottericalt.com ...


TOPICS: Apologetics; Catholic
KEYWORDS: bookreview
Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first previous 1-20 ... 761-780781-800801-820821-822 next last
To: metmom
The priest has no such power. What delusions of grandeur.

But a Pope declared his writings were free from anything meriting censure! Of course, whether even his canonization is infallible can see debate.

781 posted on 03/26/2014 7:48:15 PM PDT by daniel1212 (Come to the Lord Jesus as a contrite damned+destitute sinner, trust Him to save you, then live 4 Him)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 780 | View Replies]

To: daniel1212
when moral lapses by clerics came to light, pains were now taken to hush them up as matters of grievous scandal.

Nothing new under the sun.

Long before the Reformation itself, the unity of the Christian Church in the West had been severely undermined

Considering his preceding statement, 'severely undermined' seems pretty tame.

It is against this background of a profoundly shaken ecclesial consciousness that we are to understand that Luther, in the conflict between his search for salvation and the tradition of the Church, ultimately came to experience the Church, not as the guarantor, but as the adversary of salvation.

From a modern Pope no less.

He then sought the help of the city prefect (the first occasion of a Pope in enlisting the civil power against his adversaries)

366, when the papacy took the secular sword, when the Kingdom of God, the one not of this world departed as the Pope sought the kingdom of this world.

782 posted on 03/26/2014 7:54:00 PM PDT by xone
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 772 | View Replies]

To: terycarl; metmom
I was taught by the Catholic Church that Christ was God.....Father, Son, Holy Spirit....three persons, one God, remember now??? Why would Christ be a mediator????....He's the real thing!!

Don't you have I Timothy 2:5,6 in your Bible?

For there is one God, and one mediator also between God and men, the man Christ Jesus, who gave Himself as a ransom for all, the testimony given at the proper time.

783 posted on 03/26/2014 8:05:26 PM PDT by boatbums (Simul justis et peccator.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 711 | View Replies]

To: daniel1212
But a Pope declared his writings were free from anything meriting censure!

Well, there you have it. If he said so, it has to be true.

How convenient......

784 posted on 03/26/2014 8:32:17 PM PDT by metmom (...fixing our eyes on Jesus, the Author and Perfecter of our faith....)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 781 | View Replies]

To: Elsie

Ah that is easy. Would you like to discuss?


785 posted on 03/26/2014 8:32:36 PM PDT by redleghunter (But let your word 'yes be 'yes,' and your 'no be 'no.' Anything more than this is from the evil one.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 769 | View Replies]

To: terycarl
I was taught by the Catholic Church that Christ was God.....Father, Son, Holy Spirit....three persons, one God, remember now??? Why would Christ be a mediator????....He's the real thing!!

Well, the Catholic church teaches wrong then because there's only ONE mediator between god and man, and that's Jesus Christ.

It says so right here in the Bible that the Catholic church claims it wrote.

1 Timothy 2:5 For there is one God, and there is one mediator between God and men, the man Christ Jesus,

786 posted on 03/26/2014 8:35:56 PM PDT by metmom (...fixing our eyes on Jesus, the Author and Perfecter of our faith....)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 711 | View Replies]

To: Elsie

Wow an entire Mormon policy addressing your use of their products:)

If you need protective coverage PM me:)


787 posted on 03/26/2014 8:39:36 PM PDT by redleghunter (But let your word 'yes be 'yes,' and your 'no be 'no.' Anything more than this is from the evil one.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 770 | View Replies]

To: terycarl; Elsie
I think that He meant that whatever the Catholic Church declares to be in error on Earth, will be considered in error in Heaven....They have the power to bind, declare truth, and to loose, declare error.....Protestantism is in error.

So, when in 1302, Pope Boniface VIII issued the Papal bull Unam sanctam, which declared that outside of the Roman Catholic Church, "there is neither salvation nor remission of sins" and that, "Furthermore, we declare, we proclaim, we define that it is absolutely necessary for salvation that every human creature be subject to the Roman Pontiff.", he was not making a binding on heaven and earth infallible statement???

You come along and contradict that by saying "Protestants" CAN be Christians and be saved without belonging to and being obedient to the Roman Catholic Church. Do you, as a member of the Catholic Church, have that same authority to bind and loose? Are you your own pope by doing that?

788 posted on 03/26/2014 8:53:10 PM PDT by boatbums (Simul justis et peccator.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 748 | View Replies]

To: Elsie; terycarl
Luther's actions,however, directly attacked the authority of the church and probably caused the loss of millions of souls.

PROBABLY???

Codswallop! NO power or person on earth can prevent the Holy Spirit from reaching the hearts of those who diligently seek God.

789 posted on 03/26/2014 8:58:37 PM PDT by boatbums (Simul justis et peccator.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 753 | View Replies]

To: Elsie
If your vaunted Leaders had NOT been such EVIL men, then the whole Luther thing would have NEVER happened. Look in the mirror and accept just a LITTLE bit of responsibility; ok?

They will only accept thanks for giving the world the Bible. ;o)

790 posted on 03/26/2014 9:00:04 PM PDT by boatbums (Simul justis et peccator.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 754 | View Replies]

To: daniel1212

Thanks quite a history there. I might add Pope Damasus is no doubt on the papal roles as being one in the “unbroken line” of popes which asserts the apostolic line. Even with the edge of the sword.


791 posted on 03/26/2014 9:05:00 PM PDT by redleghunter (But let your word 'yes be 'yes,' and your 'no be 'no.' Anything more than this is from the evil one.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 772 | View Replies]

To: Elsie

I am sure you have a Dilbert cartoon supporting these unofficial official policies:) It just oozes Dilbert.


792 posted on 03/26/2014 9:06:52 PM PDT by redleghunter (But let your word 'yes be 'yes,' and your 'no be 'no.' Anything more than this is from the evil one.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 770 | View Replies]

To: metmom
The rest of the Catholic priests simply broke their vows of celibacy and fornicated.

Many, and monks. Then you have "Christians" today today who argue fornication is not forbidden in the Bible, only with prostitutes! Cause they know for sure how the word was used in post-classical Greek,. One even asserted Paul could not read Hebrew (he must have only been able to speak it and understand it orally: Acts 21:40; 22:2; 26:14).

I want to ask them then, why kind of context does it sanction sexual relations in? You know, like Mt. 19:4-6?

793 posted on 03/26/2014 9:25:07 PM PDT by daniel1212 (Come to the Lord Jesus as a contrite damned+destitute sinner, trust Him to save you, then live 4 Him)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 777 | View Replies]

To: xone
366, when the papacy took the secular sword, when the Kingdom of God, the one not of this world departed as the Pope sought the kingdom of this world.

Not a popular post.

794 posted on 03/26/2014 9:26:43 PM PDT by daniel1212 (Come to the Lord Jesus as a contrite damned+destitute sinner, trust Him to save you, then live 4 Him)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 782 | View Replies]

To: daniel1212

Quite a compilation! I know that you could have listed tons more! It seems that it is not really the “Protestants” that have a dilemma after all. ;o)


795 posted on 03/26/2014 10:05:12 PM PDT by boatbums (Simul justis et peccator.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 772 | View Replies]

To: redleghunter; Greetings_Puny_Humans; Gamecock; BlueDragon; mitch5501
Thanks quite a history there. I might add Pope Damasus is no doubt on the papal roles as being one in the “unbroken line” of popes which asserts the apostolic line. Even with the edge of the sword.

Not only. He was canonized a saint! Not sure if his sword was also. And i have read Kelly invoked for support in RC apologetics. More from same source:

Damasus enjoy the favor of court and aristocracy,... His magnificent lifestyle and hospitality help to break down the anti-Christian prejudices of upper-class pagan families. He was active in repressing heresies, including Arianism, and did not scruple to call in the secular power... His measures against the intransigently Nicene disciples of Lucifer of Cagliari (d. 370/ 1) were particularly brutal...

In 378, he persuaded the government to recognize the holy see as a court of first instance and also of appeal for the Western episcopate... In tune with his ideas, Theodosius 1 (379-95) declared (February 27, 380) Christianity the state religion in that form from which the Romans had once [imagined they] received from St. Peter, and Damasus of Rome and Peter of Alexandria now professed; for Damasus this primacy was not based on decisions of synods, as were the claims of Constantinople, but exclusively on his [presumption of] being the direct successor of St. Peter and so the rightful heir of the promises made to him by Christ (Mt. 16:18) [although many "church fathers"did not interpret that text as such].

And the election account is supported in the work of Duffy (Pontifical Historical Commission, Professor of the History of Christianity at the University of Cambridge, and former President of Magdalene College):

Damasus’ grass-roots supporters included squads of the notoriously hard-boiled Roman fossores, [actually a minor order in the church, made up of catacomb diggers generally armed with picks], and they massacred 137 followers of the rival Pope Ursinus in street-fighting that ended in a bloody siege of what is now the church of Santa Maria Maggiore”.

What genuinely gave bishops of Rome the impetus to expand further was the conversion of Constantine. Eamon Duffy noted that this event “propelled the bishops of Rome into the heart of the Roman establishment. Already powerful and influential men, they now became grandees on a par with the wealthiest senators in the city. Bishops all over the Roman world would now be expected to take on the role of judges, governors, great servants of state..- “Saints and Sinners,” New Haven and London: Yale University Press, 1997, 2001, pp. 37-38; http://beggarsallreformation.blogspot.com/2010/11/scott-windsor-3-defense-of-papacy-from.html

Then you have this:

Klaus Schatz, in his Papal Primacy: From its Origins to the Present, not only acknowledges that in the case of the process of the development of “the historically developed papacy” the initial phases of this long process “extended well into the fifth century” (Schatz pg 36)

And from John F. O'Grady, priest of the Diocese of Albany New York and professor of biblical theology at Barry University in Miami, and author of seventeen books:

”The study of the New Testament demonstrates that the apostles, in fact, had no successors, nor did the twelve.”

Many Roman Catholics assume that after the death of Peter every bishop of Rome was aware of the special authority he inherited as the successor of the chief of the apostles. To explain the lack of any evidence of the exercise of such a universal power, (emphasis added) apologists replied that the circumstances did not merit any intervention..

.Contemporary theologians are more aware of the lack of conclusive evidence documenting any understanding in the early Church of a universal role for the bishop of Rome. The earliest fathers of the Church cited to support these views, Clement of Rome, Ignatius and Irenaeus, do not offer undisputed evidence and therefore their arguments cannot be used without some reservation.” pp. 119 ,125

More .

Which leads to the "no true Catholic" response:

"No true Catholic would deny that Scripture (via Matthew 16:18) clearly and unequivocally established Apostle Peter as the Rock upon which Christ's Church, the Roman Catholic Church was founded. [thus some "Church Fathers" were not Catholic] True Catholics only accept the arguments of true Catholics. This is as it should be, and definitely how God intends His followers to follow and obey His divinely established Teaching Office, the Magisterium. Further, no true Catholic would deign to privately interpret the Magisterium's infallible teachings." - http://beggarsallreformation.blogspot.com/2010/11/built-on-sinking-sand-scriptural_27.html

Which is worthy reading, as is this .

796 posted on 03/26/2014 11:11:17 PM PDT by daniel1212 (Come to the Lord Jesus as a contrite damned+destitute sinner, trust Him to save you, then live 4 Him)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 791 | View Replies]

To: boatbums; redleghunter

Good discussion here also: http://beggarsallreformation.blogspot.com/2010/10/tying-up-some-loose-ends-from-yesterday.html


797 posted on 03/27/2014 1:12:10 AM PDT by daniel1212 (Come to the Lord Jesus as a contrite damned+destitute sinner, trust Him to save you, then live 4 Him)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 795 | View Replies]

To: daniel1212
Details - da debble's in 'em.


Those who do not LEARN from history...

798 posted on 03/27/2014 4:13:15 AM PDT by Elsie (Heck is where people, who don't believe in Gosh, think they are not going...)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 772 | View Replies]

To: Gamecock

None of these revelations are Faith building!

Shame on you!!

—Wannabe_Catholic_Dude(Mary; pray for these folks...)


799 posted on 03/27/2014 4:16:06 AM PDT by Elsie (Heck is where people, who don't believe in Gosh, think they are not going...)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 778 | View Replies]

To: daniel1212; teppe
“With regard to the mystic body of Christ, that is, all the faithful, the priest has the power of the keys, or the power of delivering sinners from hell, of making them worthy of paradise, and of changing them from the slaves of Satan into the children of God.

No, no, NO!!!

The MORMON's have the 'keys'!

And the Priesthood; too!


http://eom.byu.edu/index.php/Keys_of_the_Priesthood

800 posted on 03/27/2014 4:19:44 AM PDT by Elsie (Heck is where people, who don't believe in Gosh, think they are not going...)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 779 | View Replies]


Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first previous 1-20 ... 761-780781-800801-820821-822 next last

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.

Free Republic
Browse · Search
Religion
Topics · Post Article

FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson