[Elsie]

What you haven't done is explain why Christ said,

It's YOUR strawman: YOU explain it.

I'm still waiting on WHY catholics claim Jesus CHANGED Simon's name, when Scripture CLEARLY indicates he was known as PETER before Jesus ever mentioned it.

[JustSayNoToNannies]

What you haven't done is explain why Christ said, [TEXT OMITTED BY ELSIE: "And I tell you that you are Peter." Did He think Peter had forgotten his name?]

It's YOUR strawman: YOU explain it.

It's not a "strawman" but the words of the Lord as recorded in Scripture. Are you going to answer the question or continue to evade, bob, and weave?