I think the details are irrelevant. The main point is that one needs to have a heart for Jesus and His all sufficient atonement only with no “in betweens” or “stand in”. Also that works or efforts on our part are irrelevant until after salvation.
One cannot make a personal judgment about anyone else’s salvation.
That belongs to God alone.
St. Paul said he didn’t judge even himself.
Neither you nor I can or should evaluate the way of another’s heart for Jesus. Jesus, as God Incarnate, deals with each of us on a strictly personal level, as He alone understands how we are made, what graces we need from Him, what is best for us as the unique creation He made.
When offering Scriptural quotes to someone, supposedly for their enlightenment, the details are always relevant.
I think I have expressed myself clearly about this and don’t need to say anymore.