So, you are actually dragging posts from OTHER THREADS to show that someone has made it personal? What about not dragging disputes from thread to thread?
Dr. E., if you want I would be happy to post links from threads where you had some posts removed. Stuff that would probably have gotten a newcomer banned.
That is mind-reading and making it personal.
When I asked him to stop doing so, he accused me of threatening him with the rules. I explained to him that his other remarks which broke the rules had been deleted and he should stop breaking the rules.
That is not carrying over the argument. That is showing Natural Law his posts had been deleted which broke the rules, something he may have been unaware of. If he had been aware those posts had been removed, then a logical conclusion would be he continued to break the rules not out of ignorance, but spite. Who knows?