Almost exactly my story as well.
After I found Christ, I went back to the Catholic church as well, having been the church I was raised in.
I could not reconcile the inconsistencies between what was the plain reading of Scripture. I visited an Evangelical church and vacillated between the two for several months.
I wasn’t sure how my family would react but decided that it was a risk I had to take, and finally left the RCC.
Both of you made a conscious decision, after thoughtful consideration, to leave the Catholic Church.
I made a conscious decision, after thoughtful consideration, to be baptized into the Catholic Church.
Neither of you has the intention to leave the present course of your Christian life.
Likewise, I have no intention of leaving the Catholic Church.
This is really is the bottom line, as I see it.
My whole life is entrusted to the Lord and I am at peace to let Him sort all this out on the Last Day.