[Dr. Eckleburg]

FOREST KEEPER: ...quoting from a website of an organization APPROVED by the Vatican?

WAGGLEBEE: She didn't she posted from a BLOG. Which is fairly typical of what some routinely attempt to pass-off as "official Catholic websites".

Ah, but she did.

If you had read the website you would see that the Roman Catholics who run the site said the Legion of Mary is approved by the Vatican.

If you doubt the veracity of these Roman Catholics, your argument is with them, not me.

[Cronos]

If you had read the website you would see that the Roman Catholics who run the site said the Legion of Mary is approved by the Vatican.

That doesn't translate that
1.the BLOGsite and / or anything on the BLOGsite is approved by the Legion of Mary (it's a blog -- is it the official blog of the Legion of Mary --NO. Is it a blog of a member or is it a non-member putting up this blog?
2. the BLOGsite and / or anything on the BLOGsite is approved by the Vatican -- the Vatican doesn't go around approving every BLOG that a person who says they are Catholic posts. unlike the OPC with it's 200 members, The Church has a few more....

[Cronos]

Oooh, ooh, there's a BLOG there that shows that OPCers are really just Mormons but worship MAchen. That Blog says that it's part of the OPC, so it MUST be correct. If you doubt the veracity of the BLOGGers, your argument is with them, not me.

I can just post links to every BLOG I see and state it is an official OPC/Baptist/Presbyterian/Reformed etc. and if a OPCer/Baptist/Prebyterian/Reformed has a problem with my statement copied from the BLOG by a supposedly OPC/Baptist/... person, then that is your problem with the blogger, take it up with the Blogger, not me, I'm just posting links from crystallinks etc.

[wmfights]

If you had read the website you would see that the Roman Catholics who run the site said the Legion of Mary is approved by the Vatican.

Are these the folks that wear the brown thing around their neck so Mary will get them out of purgatory sooner?

[wagglebee]

If you had read the website you would see that the Roman Catholics who run the site said the Legion of Mary is approved by the Vatican.

First of all, it's a BLOG.

Secondly, the fact that the Church approves of the existence of the Legion of Mary IS NOT validation for everything that the members of the Legion of Mary say.

The OPC has now or in the recent past had ordained ministers that believe in racial segregation and deny the Holocaust. If one was to follow your logic, that would mean that the OPC believes in segregation and denies the Holocaust and that the OPC members share this mindset.