Posted on 02/15/2003 8:38:34 AM PST by Empireofhawks
A few weeks ago my son got into trouble at school, nothing serious, but the school wanted him to go through a process of what is called restorative justice. I agreed after I learned that Florida Governor Jeb Bush and several other leaders in the GOP support this idea. We were referred to a group called the Council on Reconciliation and Restorative and Transformative Justice (CORRTJ). It was not until after the dust had settled that we discovered what we had gotten ourselves into.
Historically, parcticing Quakers have always been true pacifists, and have never given political alegance to any president or political parts.
I've never had problems with "true, religious" pacifists. I once had the chance to get to know a CO who refused to pick up a gun for battle, but when he was drafted, he didn't run, just announced his opposition to participating in battle, and volunteered for the medical services. He became a medic, and was exposed to enemy fire on more than one occasion. He was one of the bravest men I ever met.
Mark
Principles of Restorative Justice
1. Law and justice are not synonymous terms.
I don't think that most of us would disagree with this one. There have been (and currently are) many unjust laws on the books. Of course, I suppose it depends on "whose ox is being gored."
2. Restorative justice requires a balanced focus on the needs of offenders, victims and community.
Whoa there Nellie! The order should be 1) Victims and 2) Community. The focus on the offender should be in making sure that the offender doesn't do it again!
3. Ownership of the restorative process must belong to the community.
I have to agree with this to some extent: However, the victim should be "restored" as well. And the victim should be querried on how the acts of the offender affected his or her life, or the lives of the victim's survivors.
4.There is no such thing as a victimless crime. Every crime has at least one victim - the offender.
I strongly disagree here in the vast majority of cases, but I do agree in some specific cases. First, the disagreements. Classifing "offenders" as victims is demeaning to the REAL victims. What you've got here is moral relativism, and an attempt to keep from assessing blame, i.e. that a person is responsible for their actions! It's sort of like saying that the lady who was just convicted of murdering her husband (by running him over multiple times) was a victim of her husband. SHE WAS NOT A VICTIM!!!!! Her husband may have really pissed her off by having an affair, but she made the decision to run him over, and then turn the car around and do it again! Or like saying the Menendez brothers are victims of child abuse (never proven), and now they're really victims, since they're orphans!
On the other hand, there two classes of "victimless crime," where the offender can be a victim. In illegal possession and use of drugs, if the offender has no dependants, and is putting nobody in direct peril (or indirect, for that matter), when he or she is busted, then they can become a victim of the WOD. In the second case, when it comes to prostitution, many of the ladies are very much victims of both their johns, as well as the legal system. I can't think of other cases where I agree with this item...
4. Offenders, victims and community members must reach consensus on what needs to be done to heal the harm of crime.
WRONG!!!! The offender should NOT be consulted on their punishment! That's up to the community (i.e. the courts) with input from the victims!
5. Offender and victim participation in the restorative process must be voluntary.
Yeah, right... "Excuse me, convicted murderer, but would you mind spending the next 50 years in prison?" I remember when I got into trouble for some acts of "juvinile delinquency." I committed some property crimes, and nobody asked me what I thought that felt I should do. I was punnished severely, in addition to paying restitution for the damage I caused. That's how it should have been. I should have known better than to do what I did, but I guess there was a "lapse of judgement." Well, that punnishment made sure that there were never any other lapses.
6. The restorative process must be culturally sensitive.
Just what the hell does that mean? Does this mean that certain groups should have different punnishments? What sort of nonsense is this?
7. Opportunities for healing offenders, victims and community must occur at four levels: physical, psychological, emotional and spiritual.
Yeah, right... See the comment for #6!
8. Success is full reintegration into the community for offenders and victims upon completion of the restorative contract.
More nonsense... What the hell does this mean? At what point is the victim no longer a part of the community? Of course, in a murder case, I guess I can support that... "When the victim is no longer dead, we'll let you (the offender) out of jail." More "new age" nonsense!
9. Offenders and victims work together to find that of G-d in each other, for the benefit of the common good of the community.
Wait a minute, they used the "G" word! They can't do that, not in a governmental sense! [/Sarcasm]. Of course, I suppose that if they use the word "G-d" in the "traditional, Judeo-Christian sense, there would be quite an outcry, but if they use it in a new age, touchy-feely sense, it would be OK. As long as the "G-d" they're refering to doesn't have any hard and fast rules.
Grrrrrr... This stuff really pisses me off!
Mark
FLORIDA RESTORATIVE JUSTICE PROCLAMATION
WHEREAS, crime affects not only individuals but also entire communities. Crime and fear destroy our trust in others and in our institutions, threatening the community's health and prosperity; and
WHEREAS, The Restorative Justice Ministry Network of North America is looking beyond our current criminal justice system and looking to the Bible for concepts and solutions; and
WHEREAS, The Restorative Justice Ministry Network is a Christ-centered, interdenominational, criminal justice ministry that strives to reach criminal offenders, victims and criminal justice professionals. Their mission is "networking with individuals and organizations to collaborate in creating and implementing Biblical solutions to the Criminal Justice mission field";and
WHEREAS, The Restorative Justice Ministry Network will acknowledge April 14-21, 2002, as Restorative Justice Week;
NOW, THEREFORE, I, Jeb Bush, Governor of the State of Florida, do hereby extend greetings and best wishes to all observing Restorative Justice Week, April 14-21, 2002.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I
have hereunto set my hand
and caused the Great Seal of
the state of Florida to be affixed
at Tallahassee, the Capital, this
4th day of March in the year
of our Lord two thousand two.
Now how does the Senate stay in session without a quorum? Any Ideas? Maybe some other Ratty Rat would know.... reckon?
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.